Saturday, September 15, 2018

#Atif Mian - Religious bias okayed in naya #Pakistan



Pervez Hoodbhoy

IT’S always been easy for power-seeking Pakistani clerics and politicians to set our simple-minded religious masses on fire. But, as Prime Minister Imran Khan just discovered, jumping on to a man-eating tiger’s back is one thing; getting off is another. The saga of the Economic Advisory Committee appointment of Prof Atif Mian, a distinguished economist at Princeton University, tells of this.
It all began with Imran Khan reaching out for professional help to manage Pakistan’s failing economy. To his credit Imran Khan recognises that competence counts; professionalism is precisely what made his cancer hospital work. And so he went ahead, acting just as any true liberal (Khan says he hates liberals) would — focusing upon merit, and reaching across Pakistan and outside to find advisers like Mian.
To be honest, it wasn’t much of a proposition. The advisory position offered, then rescinded, was salary-less. The committee of 18 unpaid members of the EAC is tasked with conjuring up a wish list but, as with other such government advisory committees, such recommendations are not binding. No one takes unpaid advice very seriously. Even if things had worked out, Mian would not have moved to Pakistan from his tenured university position. Nor, given other professional commitments, could he have spent much time upon Pakistan’s multiple economic crises.
To wilfully use religious sentiment for worldly gain is now firmly part of Pakistan’s political culture.
Nevertheless, the outcry that followed Mian’s appointment showed that many cannot stomach the idea of an Ahmadi being invited onto an official body. For them this is a slippery slope leading down to the unthinkable: a day when Ahmadis would be accepted as normal citizens of Pakistan.
The backlash came from within PTI and from without. The strongest pressure to dismiss Atif Mian came from right-wing and centre-right parties — JUI(F), PML-N, MMA and JI. But even the nominally secular ANP, which lost hundreds of its members to Taliban suicide attacks, hit its political opponent with a religious club. This time around the PPP stayed mum, but then it has plenty of old baggage which it cannot readily explain away.
To its credit, Imran Khan’s team jumped straight in to defend Mian’s appointment. Information Minister Fawad Chaudhry tweeted that, “Pakistan belongs as much to its minorities as it does to the majority”. In another country this would have been considered unremarkable; here it was a veritable bombshell.
A still stouter defence followed: “If you think that we should drown all our minorities in the Arabian Sea, or that they have no rights here, they have no religious or economic freedom, or freedom to live, then this must be your opinion only. Our interpretation of the state of Madina is that Islam means security, peace and moving forward together … Because of these things [persecution of minorities] the entire world makes fun of us.”
Chaudhry’s tweets struck a sympathetic chord with the Minister of Human Rights, Dr Shireen Mazari (Columbia University, PhD thesis on the revolutionary communist thinker Gramsci), who chirped right back: “Exactly. Well put indeed. Time to reclaim space for the Quaid’s Pakistan!”
Almost unable to believe their own ears, liberal Pakistanis danced with joy. Naya Pakistan was for real and not, as they had long suspected, a fraudulent slogan to seize power. We were on the way — at least by a little bit — towards making a country where every citizen would be considered equal to any other. It was not to be.
What’s especially surprising is that we have been here before. Back in 2014, perched atop his container, Imran Khan promised a cheering crowd that he believed in meritocracy and, as an example, would appoint Mian as the kind of expert he wanted to take charge of Pakistan’s economy. Days later, upon being informed that Mian was Ahmadi, he did a swift U-turn. No one I know quite understands why there was a second U-turn and why Mian was again asked.
Still, many hoped, this time it would be different. Now that Imran Khan was prime minister and had power, he would surely take a stand in support of the constitutional rights of all citizens. This after all should be his obligation as the head of the government.
The swiftness of his climbdown surprised everyone because typically a new government feels strongest in its early days. Also, unlike the previous government, the present one has support from the army and a blind cult following. Nevertheless, fear of political opponents exploiting religious sensitivities left it paralysed.
In an attempt to quash the controversy, Imran Khan recorded and uploaded his video message. One sees an embattled man seeking to wriggle out of a bad situation. Looking haggard and aged rather than his handsome self, he swears repeatedly to the end-of-prophethood while jabbing his finger at an unnamed maulana (Fazlur Rahman?) who he accuses of playing religious politics.
Of course, Khan is correct. But, unfortunately, the wily maulana is not the only one playing this game. Had a similar matter come up before Khan became prime minister, what would have been his stance? One recalls the pictures of Imran Khan participating in numerous khatm-i-nabuwat meetings, some addressed by the most extreme of clerics. Where the goal is to obtain or retain political power, he was willing to say or do whatever it took no matter how hateful.
In a few days, the Atif Mian episode will recede into the background. Still, it warns of the dangers ahead. Imran Khan — like Zulfikar Ali Bhutto and Nawaz Sharif before him — will have to navigate a minefield where a misstep can cost you a limb or your life. In such circumstances, fearful politicians will make concessions and principles evaporate.
No country is free of prejudices; certain groups of its own citizens are discriminated against. Still, at the very least this is normally deprecated officially and, as in some countries, one sees genuine attempts to create an equalitarian society. Pakistanis in Europe and North America take their freedoms for granted in spite of overtly projecting their identity. Still, they expect respect and mostly receive it. But in today’s Pakistan those with religious beliefs different from that of the majority’s stand little or no chance.

#PAKISTAN - #StopStateTerrorism - #PTM and arrest warrants

In worrying development, the Khyher Pakhtunkhwa (KP) police have issued arrest warrants for senior members of the Pashtun Tahafuz Movement (PTM). Among those targeted are the group’s leader Manzoor Pashteen, MNAs Ali Wazir and Mohsin Dawar along with a handful of others; including Fazal Advocate whose son was killed in the Army Public School (APS) attack.
This is not the first time that the PTM has been pressured. At the beginning of the year the young ethnic Pashtuns engaged in a long march from Waziristan to Islamabad to call for an end to the systematic and decades’-long campaign that has been waged against this community. Their only demand was and remains the fulfilment of their constitutional rights. Which is another way calling for justice. Since then, the PTM have had to fend off baseless allegations that they are on the payroll of hostile intelligence agencies; namely, India’s RAW and Afghanistan’s NDS. As part of a manufactured policy to discredit the group and drown out their legitimate grievances.
Yet in the midst of all this, the PTM found an ally in Imran Khan. Indeed, during the elections, the latter even refrained from fielding PTI candidates in areas where the PTM were contesting. But perhaps more importantly, even before being crowned Prime Minister, Khan agreed to personally plead their case before the COAS; while cautioning against ‘anti-state’ rhetoric. That members of the PTM have now been declared proclaimed offenders despite their not being informed of their involvement in a police case raises important questions.
Some pundits see the timing of the arrest warrants as suspect; coming as it did on the very day that a PTM delegation had met with the provincial governor. The fear is that this may be intended to send a strong message to PM Khan to remain within his limits. Be that as it may, it most definitely undermines long-held claims that the KP police force is the only de-politicised one in the country. And then there are the potential implications for the FATA-merger.
It is hoped that the PTI government gets to the bottom of the matter at the earliest. This is not to give the PTM an entirely clean chit. For if did hold a rally without first obtaining the required Non-Objection Certificate (NOC), it must explain itself. However, even if this were the case it could have been better dealt with by approaching the KP Chief Minister. Naturally, rule of law must apply to everyone. But when a particular group has had their fundamental rights routinely violated by various institutions, a trust deficit exists. Whereas the young PTM leaders and the Pakistani state are on the same side. For the ethnic Pashtuns have also been thrust on to the frontlines of the someone else’s war. And many of those against whom an FIR has been registered have suffered immensely at militant hands. They do not need to endure more brutality.
In short, the entire misstep has served to put the question of Pashtun rights firmly under the spotlight once more. And we are optimistic that this is where it will stay.  

#StopStateTerrorism - #PAKISTAN - Twitterati react to Punjab govt’s Muharram ad featuring Manzoor Pashteen

Twitterati have started reacting to the Punjab government’s Muharram advertisement which allegedly depicts Pashtun Tahafuz Movement (PTM) leader Manzoor Pashteen as a symbol of sectarian violence.
The ad, being aired on television with regard to Muharram, shows Pashteen while warning people to avoid sectarian violence.


Afrasiab Khattak of Awami National Party (ANP) has criticsed the act and asked the govt to ‘formally & publicly apologise for running a home department TVC showing PTM leaders as terrorists’.




The government must formally & publicly apologise for running a home department TVC yesterday on national television showing PTM leaders as terrorists. The admins of terror factories dubbing peace loving leaders of a non violent Pashtun youth struggling for HR is condemnable.

Reham Khan, ex wife of Prime Minister Imran Khan, has also took a jibe at the government for ‘this blatant use of government money by PTI in Punjab for racial profiling of Pushtuns & defaming human rights activists who are law abiding citizens.’
Admitting the mistake, the federal government took down the ad. The Federal Information Minister Fawad Chaudhry replied to Dawar that “this advertisement was immediately taken off as soon as it was brought to our attention”.
Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KP) Police on Friday issued arrest warrants for Manzoor Pashteen, MNA Ali Wazir and six others.
A letter issued by a senior police official in Swabi and sent to political agents of North and South Waziristan declared Pashteen, Wazir, Dr Said Alam Masood, Fazal Advocate, Khan Zaman, Mohsin Dawood, Samad Khan and Noorul Salam proclaimed offenders and sought their arrest in connection with a case registered against them on August 28
According to the first information report (FIR), PTM workers held a gathering at cricket stadium in Swabi’s Shah Mansoor Town without required no-objection certificate from authorities concerned.

The PTM gained momentum following the extra-judicial murder of Naqeebullah Mehsud in Karachi. It sought capital punishment for the prime suspect in Naqeebullah murder case, former Malir SSP Rao Anwar, recovery of missing persons and removal of landmines in tribal areas. A Jirga, formed by the KP Apex Committee and comprising tribal elders, is holding negotiations with the group to resolve their issues.

Only democracy is the guarantee for a stronger and prosperous Pakistan: Bilawal Bhutto

Chairman Pakistan People’s Party (PPP) Bilawal Bhutto Zardari has said that only the democracy is the guarantee for a stronger and prosperous Pakistan.

This he said in his message on the occasion of World Democracy Day, which is commemorated across the world today, September 15th.


He said that the democracy is the essence of history of mankind and despite the fact that democracy is the best form of government; it is still weak as compared to authoritarian forces in many countries of the world and especially in the third world. However, it is destined for the mankind to overcome the dictatorial rules and then democracy would prevail.
The PPP Chairman said that the challenges for the masses in Pakistan and for the democratic system are still at apex and the struggle for a better society based on equality and justice would yet go too long.


He said that besides the challenges, extremism and terrorism are two big menaces that have jeopardised the peace of the world and in Pakistan because a handful of terrorists do not want to see the world should embrace peace and tranquility. Peace and tranquility is tantamount to elimination of the extremist and terrorist forces.


Bilawal Bhutto Zardari reiterated his firm resolve for transforming Pakistan into a real federal democratic Muslim Role Model State as per the ideology of Shaheed Zulfikar Ali Bhutto and per the vision of Shaheed Mohtarma Benazir Bhutto.
He vowed the PPP would take the struggle to its logical end and won’t hesitate for the sacrifices.



https://mediacellppp.wordpress.com/2018/09/14/only-democracy-is-the-guarantee-for-a-stronger-and-prosperous-pakistan-bilawal-bhutto-zardari/

Friday, September 14, 2018

خشک سالی، بلاول بھٹو کی وزیراعلیٰ سندھ کو الرٹ رہنے کی ہدایت

پیپلز پارٹی کے چیئرمین بلاول بھٹو زرداری نے حکومت سندھ کو تھرپارکر سمیت صوبے کے دیگر علاقوں میں بارش نہ ہونے کے باعث پیدا ہونے والی صورتحال پر الرٹ رہنے کی ہدایت کردی ہے ۔
بلاول ہائوس میں پی پی چیئرمین نے وزیراعلیٰ سندھ سید مراد علی شاہ سے ملاقات کی اور کہا کہ سندھ حکومت نے عوام کی توقعات پر پورا اترنا ہے۔
انہوں نے کہا کہ بہتر حکمت عملی اور حکمرانی سے خشک سالی سے متاثر علاقوں کے حالات کو قابو اور بہتر بنایا جاسکتا ہے۔
بلاول بھٹو کا کہنا تھا کہ ان کی خواہش ہے کہ وہ عوام کی توقعات کے مطابق صوبہ سندھ کو ترقی یافتہ اور خوشحال دیکھنا چاہتے ہیں۔
ملاقات کے دوران وزیراعلیٰ مراد علی شاہ نے پارٹی چیئرمین کو ترقیاتی کاموں اور حکومت سندھ کی جانب سے آئندہ سالوں کے لئے زیرغور منصوبوں کے متعلق بریفنگ دی۔
https://jang.com.pk/news/550265

#Pakistan - FOUR SENIOR SHIA ISLAMIC SCHOLARS GAGGED AS NO CHANGE SEEN UNDER PTI GOVT

Pakistani Shia Muslims see no change even under the government of Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf because ban on entry and speeches of many qualified, senior, law-abiding, pro-peace and moderate Shia Islamic scholars continues. Allama Sheikh Mohsin Ali Najafi, Allama Shifa Najafi, Allama Amin Shaheedi and Allama Raja Nasir Abbas Jafari are not allowed to address Majalis (mourning congregations).

These four qualified and senior Islamic scholars have no history of sectarianism. They always preach love, peace, unity and tolerance. They promote Islamic values and highlight the sacrifices of great Martyrs of Karbala and their leader Imam Hussain (AS) against the forces of tyranny.
It is also very much unfortunate that Allama Raja Nasir, Majlis-e-Wahdat-e-Muslimeen’s secretary general, is also named in the list of those gagged by PTI government. Allama Raja Nasir-led MWM remained an ally of PTI in elections 2018.
Shia Muslims demand that they would not tolerate gagging of law-abiding and qualified senior Islamic scholars. They said change has not come to Pakistan even under the PTI government of Imran Khan and incumbent government too continues to equate the victims of terrorism with the perpetrators of terrorism. They turned down this discriminatory policy targeting Shia Muslims and their qualified religious scholars who never preached anything that could be said violation of law.

a

#Pakistan - #Baluchistan - Dera Bugti women suffer due to absence of gynecologist



Mehnaz Bibi was being rushed to the hospital in a critical condition after her condition deteriorated. She was being shifted all the way from Dera Bugti to Rahim Yar Khan for treatment when she breathed her last.
The absence of a gynecologist at the district headquarter hospital in the downtrodden Dera Bugti had cost the pregnant lady her life, and there’s nothing her family was able to do about it.
Sadly, this is not the first woman in the district who died due to maternal complications.
According to Mehnaz’s family, many women and their children had died in the district as no lady gynecologist offered her services at the medical facility.
The maternal mortality rate has risen sharply in Dera Bugti since the past year. At least six such cases have been reported since last month, while the number has reached 21 in 2018.
Refuting the allegations the officials of District Health Department said, the prime cause of maternal mortalities in Dera Bugti were lack of awareness among women and families.
“In many cases pregnant women dies due to inappropriate care and lack of healthy foods which causing maternal mortalities in the District.” Health officials said adding lady gynecologist has been performing her duties from past many days and routinely checking maternal cases.

Tacit impunity for Pakistan as NSA Bolton raises nuclear alarm

By VIVEK KATJU

Occasionally, very occasionally, a relatively brief and unexpected comment throws unexpected light on what drives a policy. It can also highlight its severe limitations, and lay bare what is generally left unsaid or is deliberately obfuscated.
US National Security Adviser John Bolton’s response to a question about America’s Pakistan policy did exactly this just two days ago.
Bolton addressed the Federalist Society in Washington DC on September 10 on the topic of the International Criminal Court’s request for permission to investigate some US defense and intelligence personnel for “alleged war crimes”.
During the question and answer session that followed his speech a Pakistani journalist asked a question unrelated to the ICC. Instead, he asked about Imran Khan’s electionand the suspension of military assistance to Pakistan.
Bolton referred to Secretary of State Mike Pompeo’s August 6 visit to Islamabad and said, “He wanted to convey the message that we hoped and expected that Pakistan would cooperate fully in the war against terrorism which they had committed to do. It was before my time but the Trump administration did not take the decision to cancel a substantial part of the military aid package to Pakistan lightly. It was done knowing full well that Pakistan is a nuclear weapons state and the risk that the government could fall into the hands of terrorists who would get control of those nuclear weapons was particularly serious. But it is a serious problem on the sub-continent and I hope it’s one that the new government of Pakistan addresses because this terrorist threat is a threat, I think, to the majority of the people in Pakistan not to the terrorists and not to the some of their supporters in the military and elsewhere. It’s a matter of extra-ordinary importance to the United States and one that we hope that the new government addresses”.
The fear of Pakistani nuclear weapons falling into terrorists’ hands has existed since the 1990s. In an article in the New York Times in April 2017 Rahmatullah Nabil, the former head of Afghan intelligence, claimed that internal Pakistani classified documents had expressed concerns regarding terrorists’ threats to the country’s nuclear assets. However the underlying assumption has always been that the terrorists may be able to get hold of nuclear weapons and materials through subverting the system.
Never has an assertion been voiced as Bolton has done: that the government itself may be taken over by terrorists. This is dramatic because Bolton said that the “risk” of such an eventuality was “particularly serious”. Prima-facie, Bolton’s comment indicates a fear that the entire state apparatus, both civil and military, is at “risk” of falling into terrorist hands.
This implication is warranted for the Strategic Plans Division (SPD). Headed by a three-star general, the SPD acts as a secretariat of the National Command Authority which is chaired by the Prime Minister.
The Authority is, as the policy document setting up Pakistan’s Nuclear Command and Control system states, “responsible for policy formulation, and will exercise employment and development control over all strategic nuclear forces and strategic organizations”.
The SPD is entirely controlled by the Pakistan military even if, as Pakistan’s foremost expert on the country’s nuclear policies and structures, Naeem Salik says, “not the conventional military”. The security division of the SPD is headed by a two-star general and is “responsible for physical security, personnel security and counter-intelligence”. Naturally, Pakistan has always asserted that its weapons are entirely safe.
The underlying but obvious thought behind Bolton’s assertion is that since Pakistan’s nuclear assets are in danger of falling into terrorists’ hands, nothing should be done to impair its military as it is the institution which guards, if not, as it is widely believed, controls these assets. Only then would a decision to suspend a part of the military aid package be such a big deal and not be “taken lightly”. This also explains why the US has been willing to live with Pakistan’s duplicity on Afghanistan.
President Trump has himself vented his frustration on Pakistan’s behavior. He tweeted on New Year’s Day, “The United States has foolishly given Pakistan over 33 billion dollars in aid over the last 15 years, and they have given us nothing but lies and deceit, thinking of our leaders as fools. They give safe havens to the terrorists we hunt in Afghanistan, with little help. No more!”. Despite these strong words, action has been limited to putting economic pressure on Pakistan through suspending military assistance and the Financial Action Task Force. Pakistan has absorbed all this pressure.
Significantly, the army has not been touched at all. No sanctions have been imposed on any of its personnel. This is notwithstanding its direct role in aiding the Taliban, which through its actions has killed about 2500 US service personnel in Afghanistan and has been responsible for America’s longest war, one still with no end in sight. US restraint against the Pakistan army has naturally resulted in it feeling immune from any real action against it. It has, therefore, no incentive to change what it is doing in Afghanistan.
Bolton reiterated what the US has been asking Pakistan to do for years: contribute to controlling terrorism. But if terrorism is responsible for US restraint, why would the Pakistan army seek to control it? Logic dictates that it is then in Pakistan’s interest to let terrorism proceed, for it represents a shield that prevents the US from taking decisive action, confining itself to steps that Pakistan can absorb.
Bolton’s fear that terrorists have supporters in “the military and elsewhere” is also noteworthy but needs a nuanced understanding. There is no doubt that religiosity has risen very substantially in the army since the Islamization policy undertaken by President General Zia-ul-Haq in the late 1970s and 1980s. There may be supporters of the terrorists’ objectives among high-ranking military figures, and the army leadership uses terrorists to promote Pakistan’s external interests.
Certainly, it is not in the generals’ interest to allow an increase of terrorists’ influence or support in the army. Equally certainly, it is in the US and the international community’s interest not to permit Pakistan, especially its army, impunity over its use of terrorists. Comments such as those of John Bolton and the thinking on which they are based, currently assure them of that impunity.

KP police issue arrest warrants against PTM's Pashteen, Wazir, six others



Arrest warrants for the chief of the Pashtun Tahaffuz Movement (PTM) Manzoor Pashteen, MNA Ali Wazir, and six others have been issued by the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KP) government, it emerged on Friday.

According to a notification issued by the Swabi Superintendent of Police and sent to political agents in Waziristan on Friday, Pashteen, Wazir, Dr Said Alam Masood, Fazal Advocate, Khan Zaman, Mohsin Dawood, Samad Khan and Noorul Salam have been named as "proclaimed offenders" and are "required to be arrested" in connection with a case registered against them on August 28.
The "case" pertains to a jalsa (gathering) which was held by the movement that day — in defiance of orders barring them from doing so — against human rights violations and for the recovery of missing persons.
PTM — a movement for the rights of those affected by the war against militancy in the tribal areas, especially South Waziristan — has been protesting in different parts of the country against enforced disappearances, extrajudicial arrests and killings, as well as the mistreatment of the Pakhtun community.
PTM first made headlines in Islamabad following the extrajudicial killing of Waziristan native Naqeebullah Mehsud — a shopkeeper and aspiring model — by police in Karachi in January.
The movement's leaders claim that in the past decade, 32,000 Pashtuns have gone missing from Fata. They insist that their struggle is to ensure implementation of the Constitution, under which law-enforcement agencies are supposed to provide details of the people they pick up and present them before courts within a stipulated time period.