Friday, August 31, 2018

Imran Khan government’s honeymoon in Pakistan looks all but over

By GUL BUKHARI
The performance of the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf government has so far only invited ridicule.

Barely a fortnight into the tenure of the new Imran Khan-led government in Pakistan, none can figure out the direction it will take on any front, be it economy, foreign affairs, security, welfare or human rights.
Far from inspiring confidence, the performance of the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) government, so far, has been theatrical and successful only in rousing ridicule or fear for the future in the public. One controversy breaks on the heels of the previous, and the honeymoon of the new government looks all but over.
Social media is abuzz with biscuit jokes because of silly, optical austerity measures that the PTI has adopted. There are also the helicopter jokes because of Khan’s daily dashes to his private estate on a helicopter that his government first denied, then defended it as a weekend activity, and finally justified with a Rs 55 per kilometre bill. Meanwhile, real issues remain out of focus.
One of the foremost concerns for the government should be the fact that the country is already on the G7 countries’ Financial Action Task Force (FATF) grey list for money laundering and terror financing, and can be black-listed soon if measures to combat terror financing are not taken up, increasing Pakistan’s isolation and economic difficulties. There has been no word on the government’s policy in this regard. Instead, foreign minister Shah Mehmood Qureshi angrily rejected the US State Department’s version of Secretary of State Mike Pompeo’s first phone call to Khan as being ‘contrary to the facts’. The State Department had said, “Secretary Pompeo raised the importance of Pakistan taking decisive action against all terrorists operating in Pakistan and its vital role in promoting the Afghan peace process.”
The US first reiterated that it stands by its read out, and then sent the transcript to Pakistan to ‘satisfy’ Islamabad that the State Department’s release was not ‘incorrect’, deeply embarrassing Pakistan domestically and internationally. Pakistan has now announced that it will ‘bury’ this issue in a U-turn on the chest thumping ahead of Pompeo’s visit early next month.
It would be pertinent to remember that in January this year, the US suspended security support to Pakistan in its war on terror to be resumed only upon ‘decisive action’ against the Haqqani Network and Afghan Taliban operating out of Pakistan. The obstinate attitude of the new government towards combating terror and unnecessary lies have left the public bemused and concerned.
In an earlier blunder, Qureshi had invented talks offer from PM Modi saying, “Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi has written a letter to PM Imran Khan in which he indicated the beginning of talks between the two countries.” The foreign ministry had to eat a humble pie after the Indian media refuted this claim. It is worrisome that instead of framing policies to resolve serious issues facing the country, the new government is relying on easily discoverable fibs.
On the $2.2 billion monthly current account deficit that Pakistan faces, Khan repeatedly talks of his plan to “bring back looted money” and appeals for charity to overseas Pakistanis, both seriously puerile plans that make for good rhetoric but not effective policy. Pakistan has lost more money over the years than the looted wealth that might actually exist, with the National Accountability Bureau’s and the Supreme Court’s populist wild goose chases abroad.
One of the most serious apprehensions about this government’s future course arose just a couple of days ago when the federal minister for human rights Shireen Mazari wrote a stinging rebuke to Brad Adams, Asia director, Human Rights Watch, in response to his letter to Prime Minister Imran Khan. The Human Rights Watch had written to Imran drawing his attention to several serious human rights concerns including enforced disappearances, curbs on freedom of expression, censorship, religious persecution, death penalty, and military courts, etc. The scale and severity of human rights violations in Pakistan make it an existential issue of democracy for the country.
Instead of a dignified response and a vow to take a corrective path to uphold Pakistan’s commitment to human rights, which would have greatly reassured Pakistan’s own citizens, Mazari wrote a hostile letter back. As anchorperson Ajmal Jami correctly stated, “It is a routine exercise that international monitoring organisations write letters to the heads of state of signatory countries after they resume office and air their concerns as did International Human Rights Watch.” But Mazari’s knee-jerk partisan response, as if to a political opponent, appeared entirely undignified and inappropriate. More importantly, the whataboutery and somewhat unlearned nature of her response was alarming for the non-hypernationalist, humanist Pakistani citizens.
“I may have missed your monitoring reports on these so would appreciate if you could refresh my memory,” wrote Mazari in reference to Indian atrocities in Kashmir, and Israel’s in Palestine. Needless to say, the HRW has done stellar monitoring work in over 90 countries including the two referred to. She also drew Adams’s attention to restrictions on Muslims’ religious freedoms in Europe. Clearly, these are valid human rights violations, but not ones the Pakistan government is answerable for.
Lawyer Reema Omer expressed her dismay on Twitter saying, “Unfortunate that Dr Mazari is unfamiliar with HRW’s global work that doesn’t just highlight rights issues in Kashmir, Palestine, Europe, but also countries that PK conveniently ignores like China, Russia, KSA. Disappointingly antagonist start to her tenure.”
Journalist Murtaza Solangi echoed my concern by saying, “She is the minister of Pakistan, not Israel or India so she would be judged on what happens in Pakistan, not what happens elsewhere.”
As a Pakistani citizen, I desperately hope that the PTI government will soon replace nationalistic rhetoric, optics and stunts with real work and get on with resolving genuine governance and policy issues. I hope I am not left holding my breath for the next five years.
https://theprint.in/opinion/imran-khan-governments-honeymoon-in-pakistan-looks-all-but-over/109435/

Multiple Violent Attacks Against Believers Reveal Just How Dangerous it is for Pakistani Christians



Emily Jones

Two recent attacks against Christians in Pakistan emphasize the worsening conditions for believers in the predominately Muslim country.
One of those incidents occurred on August 2, when Vicky Masih, 35, was murdered on his wedding anniversary.
"It was the wedding anniversary of Vicky and his wife," an advocate Tariq Zia told International Christian Concern (ICC). "Vicky was asked by his Muslim friends to meet them at Muhammad Abbas' house and celebrate with them."
"Muhammad Ilyas, another one of Vicky's Muslim friends, had to pay back a handsome loan to Vicky," Zia continued. "When Vicky asked for his money back, Muhammad Ilyas abused Vicky and said that he will teach a lesson to the choora."
"Choora" is a derogatory term used against Christians.
"Within no time, the party turned into an exchanging of harsh words, a physical clash, and ended with Vicky's murder," Zia reported.
According to Asia News, Abbas opened fire on Vicky and left him to die. Local residents eventually took him to a hospital where he was pronounced dead. He left behind a wife and three young children.
Iftikhar Saleem, the victim's younger brother, told Asia News that the police arrested the killer only after public protest.
"The police are conniving with the perpetrators, who are part of rich criminal families," he said. "We want justice...We are poor and we do not have the strength to fight these thugs. We call upon all the people of God to help us and pray for the wife of Vicky and her three little children: now they are the most vulnerable and defenseless."
Just 16 days later, Alvin John and his family were brutally attacked in the Mehmoodabad neighborhood of Karach.
He told ICC that some of his Muslim neighbors repeatedly harassed his family because of their Christian faith.
"I shifted my family to this rented house about 10 months ago," John told ICC. "At first, we were asked to leave by some Muslim neighbors because of our Christian faith. But since Easter, we have been pressurized, threatened, and teased."
"My 19-year-old daughter Aresha then became the target," John explained. "They would follow my daughter in the streets and markets, offering her a bright and secure future if she converted, and often abused her for her Christian faith."
John did his best to protect his family and find another place stay, but he says they were attacked on August 18.
"A mob of Muslims, led by Muhammad Samad Zaheer, attacked me and my family," John said. "They damaged the left eye of my son, Vickram John. Initially, the doctors have no hope for his eyesight."
"The attackers also broke most of the house stuff, furniture, doors, and windows," he continued. "We cannot go back to the house as there is unrest in the neighborhood. We are now taking shelter with relatives."
Pakistan is one of the most dangerous places in the world for Christians. It is especially dangerous for Christians who convert from Islam.
In May, the United States Commission for International Religious Freedom (USCIRF) cited Pakistan for its deteriorating human rights record.
"In 2017, religious minorities in Pakistan, including Hindus, Christians, Sikhs, Ahmadis, and Shi'a Muslims, continued to face attacks and discrimination from extremist groups and society at large," the commission stated in a report. "The government of Pakistan failed to protect these groups adequately, and it perpetrated systematic, ongoing, egregious religious freedom violations.''
http://www1.cbn.com/cbnnews/cwn/2018/august/multiple-violent-attacks-against-believers-reveal-just-how-dangerous-it-is-for-pakistani-christians

#Pakistan - #PPP to establish Zulfiquar Ali Bhutto University in #Thar

The PPP MPA from Thar Surendar Valasai has submitted the resolution for the setting up the University in Thar after the name of the founding father of Pakistan Peoples Party late Zulfiquar Ali Bhutto.
Valasai, who himself hails from Kaloi area of Thar in his resolution submitted in Sindh Assembly stated that the establishment of Shaheed Zulfiquar Ali Bhutto University in Thar would cater to the needs of the higher education with special emphasis on the subjects, which might contribute to future requirements in local as well as national development and economic activities in the desert region.
Valasai, who is also spokesperson of Bilawal House, when contacted by this reporter informed that he was assured by number of his fellow law makers to support and endorse his move in the next session of Sindh Assembly. In the wake of the massive development activities in Thar including the ongoing extraction of Thar coal reserves it was the need of the hour to set up the institutions in Thar to harness the local talent, he added.
http://www.thesindhtimes.com/sindh/ppp-establish-zulfiquar-ali-bhutto-university-thar-surendar-valasai/

Thursday, August 30, 2018

Saqi | Ajmal Khattak | Sardar Ali Takkar | ساقي | اجمل خټک | سردارعلي ټکر

Editorial: #Pakistan - No ordinary abduction - Javed Iqbal's stance that missing persons issue has been 'politicised' is most unfortunate



There can, there must, be no two views about enforced disappearances.
It is an abhorrent practice, a hallmark of some of the world’s most despotic regimes that is calculated to terrorise the people into silence. And any appearance of downplaying the gravity of this illegal act only emboldens the perpetrators.
One could argue, therefore, that retired Justice Javed Iqbal, chairman of the Commission of Inquiry on Missing Persons, took a most unfortunate stance on Tuesday while briefing the Senate Standing Committee on Human Rights. According to him, the issue of missing people “has always been politicised” and that “the situation was not as bad as it is made to sound”.
To support his contention, Mr Iqbal cited the claim of Baloch activist Mama Qadeer that 40,000 Baloch were missing, although, he said, the commission had been given no details of their disappearance; that several ostensibly missing individuals in one part of the country had been located elsewhere in Pakistan; and that a number of them may be incarcerated in Afghanistan.
The fact is, unlike an ‘ordinary’ abduction, enforced disappearances always have a political dimension. Whether Gen Pinochet in Chile from 1973 to 1990, President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi in present-day Egypt, or the Indian state against the Kashmiris — to cite but a few examples — it is a tactic employed by repressive governments that demand total compliance and carte blanche to operate.
Certainly, there can be a difference over the numbers of the missing, but the numbers are irrelevant: that it happens at all is an abomination.
The theatre of enforced disappearances has spread from the remote areas of Balochistan to the urban locale of the capital itself; earlier the targets were political activists and journalists; then bloggers — indeed anyone espousing progressive ideas — began to be picked up.
That means, there are multiple, credible eyewitness accounts of such abductions. Moreover, while Mr Iqbal offered various reasons why we should not be unduly concerned by these happenings, and even defended internment centres run by the security establishment, the commission headed by him has failed to hold anyone publicly accountable for disappearing citizens.
It was during Iftikhar Chaudhry’s tenure as Supreme Court chief justice that tough questions were asked of security forces personnel who, it is alleged, are significantly involved in enforced disappearances. In recent months, Chief Justice Saqib Nisar has also displayed a welcome resolve to hold state elements accountable for the crime.
Nevertheless, Mr Iqbal’s criticism before the Senate Committee of successive governments’ lethargy over the issue is valid, and the committee is correct in approving the idea of criminalising enforced disappearances.
Although the right to due process is guaranteed by the Constitution — a right manifestly violated when people are disappeared — such an action by parliament will convey an unequivocal message about where the people’s elected representatives stand on the matter.

Bilawal Bhutto condoles with family of late Ghulam Mujtaba Isran



Pakistan People’s Party (PPP) Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari visited the residence of late Ghulam Mujtaba Isran to condole with his family.

The PPP chairman met with the brother and son of the late leader.
He paid tribute to late Isran saying “Isran remained loyal to the party through thick and thin. He took part in every struggle for restoration and strengthening of democracy.
PPP Sindh President Nisar Ahmed Khuhro, MNA Khursheed Junejo, MPAs Suhail Anwar Sial, Genhwar Ali Khan Isran, President PPP Larkana chapter Abdul Fatah Bhutto, ex-MPA Mohammad Ali Bhutto also accompanied the PPP chairman.
Isran passed away earlier this month at the age of 75 following a prolonged illness.
He was born on December 11 in the year 1943 in Khairpur Joso village of Larkana District.
The veteran politician served the Sindh province four times as the Member of Provincial Assembly (MPA) after being elected in 1988, 1990, 1993 and 2013, respectively.

https://dailytimes.com.pk/290398/bilawal-condoles-with-family-of-late-ghulam-mujtaba-isran/

#Pakistan's Talibanization - New #Pakistani minister bans 'vulgar' movie billboards, critics fear rise of Islamists

Punjab’s new information minister, Islamist politician Fayaz-ul-Hasan Chohan, has announced a ban on “vulgar” movie billboards in the Pakistani province, angering those who fear the growing influence of hardliners under new Prime Minister Imran Khan.
Since Khan’s party appointed him last week, Chohan has caused a number of rows, including with his visit to the grave of a man sentenced to death for killing the governor of Punjab in 2011, and with critical remarks about Nargis, a popular Pakistani singer and actress.
“If any vulgar billboard is found at any cinema in Punjab after three days, there will be a fine in first place, and if any one didn’t comply, that cinema will be shut down,” Chohan told a public meeting in the eastern city of Lahore.
“Is there any humanity that you print half-naked women and put them on big billboards?” he said.
Khan’s election victory in July was helped by strong support from Islamist parties. Chohan joined Khan’s Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf, Justice Movement from the Islamist party Jamaat-e-Islami Pakistan.
“It’s pure moral policing,” the left-leaning politician and rights activist Ammar Rashid said on Twitter.

#OurProphetOurHonour - Netherlands - #Dutch cartoon contest and protests in #Pakistan: All for show?



Geert Wilders' competition as well as demands behind rallies in Pakistan only exist for attention, two analysts argue.
An announcement by Geert Wilders, a far-right Dutch opposition leader, to hold a competition for cartoons depicting Islam's Prophet Muhammad has led to protests in Pakistan, where the far-right Tehreek-e-Labbaik Pakistan (TLP) threatened to blockade Islamabad unless the country severs diplomatic relations with the Netherlands.
Physical depictions of God or the Prophet Muhammad are forbidden in Islam, and the TLP says the competition amounts to "blasphemy".
Late on Thursday, Wilders cancelled the event, citing security concerns.
According to Sehar Tariq, a counter violent extremism researcher based in Islamabad, and Stijn van Kessel, a political scientist based in London, the reason behind the announcement by Wilders' Freedom Party and the TLP's demands is the same: attention.
Both parties have not been as successful recently as they had hoped, so generating controversy is a perfect opportunity to rile up their far-right base.
Al Jazeera spoke to both experts and asked them to explain the situation both Wilders and the TLP are in.

Sehar Tariq, counter violent extremism analyst, based in Islamabad. She is also the country representative for the United States Institute of Peace (USIP).
Sehar Tariq: The Tehreek-e-Labbaik Pakistan didn't do as well at the polls as they had hoped, I think, and so this helps to bring them back to political relevance in Pakistan, and it keeps their voter base engaged. They are a single-issue party, so this is great for them, that such an event has emerged in the Netherlands.
They can use this to keep the base engaged. Without [events like Wilders' cartoon competition], they risk becoming irrelevant. This is a reminder that "Hey! We are here, and we are watching and are ready to fight on the issue of blasphemy".
So I think this protest mobilises and re-energises their voter base, which might have been feeling slightly despondent on their electoral performance. They did well by an objective standard, for a brand new party, but not based on their own standards for success, perhaps.
[The TLP won only two provincial assembly seats in Pakistan’s general election on July 25, but bagged 2.2 million votes nationwide, making it the fifth-most-popular political party in the country.]
Al Jazeera: Does holding this protest, therefore, allow them to burnish their credentials as so-called defenders of the faith?
Tariq: Absolutely. That [being defenders of the faith] is how they have set themselves up. [TLP chief] Khadim Hussain Rizvi is a preacher, and for them to generate international news with this, it not only establishes his credentials as a defender of the faith but also as someone who can stand up to the West.
That really resonates with his voter base… He is seen as a knight in shining armour, so to speak, of a Muslim world that faces the onslaught of Islamophobia by the West.
Al Jazeera: Is there an element here of both sides of the far-right getting exactly what they want?
Tariq: Absolutely. Khadim Hussain Rizvi needs someone to be Islamophobic or blasphemous for him to continue to say blasphemy is a relevant topic. If there is no blasphemy, what is he going to do? On the other hand, someone like Wilders needs someone who is out on the streets, baying for blood, so he can point to them, too.
It is kind of a symbiotic and mutually beneficial relationship. They both feed off the worst stereotypes of each other.
The worst thing is that in the media eye, this catches attention and gets amplified by both sides. It also then skews international discourse into this paradigm of a ‘clash of civilisations’.
Al Jazeera: TLP won the fifth-most number of votes in the general election - how significant is that, and what next for them?
Tariq: They are genuinely tapping into a local sentiment, and there is also a global shift happening. They have won two provincial seats. To me, the scary part is that they are the fifth-most popular political party in this country - that speaks to a societal shift that is happening in Pakistan.
What they are doing today [with the protest], is likely to help them in the upcoming local government elections, even more so than perhaps their performance in the general elections.
Right now they are a single-issue party, but I do see them, in terms of what next, expanding their list of issues - soon they will find that there may not be enough events around blasphemy to create a ruckus. Where does it go next? Non-Muslims? Minorities? Women? If they want to stay relevant, they will have to evolve into other areas.
Al Jazeera: How much of this is about religion and freedom of expression, and how much about gaining political prominence and power?
Tariq: It's entirely about political prominence and power. Wilders is a long-time politician, he has a history. These guys are new to politics, but they have had a long-standing commitment to religious propagation. It is not fair to say that none of this has to do with religion - being very cynical, the people at the top may not, but their constituents definitely do care about these issues.
It's like an "our way of life" vs "their way of life", that's the clash, and what is the ideal way of life? It's not just that they are doing it to get to political power - it's that they know if political power is defined by these issues, then they will be in power.

Stijn van Kessel, lecturer at the Queen Mary University of London, is specialised in populism, Euroscepticism and ideology, voters, members and electoral performance of (far-right) populist parties.
Al Jazeera: How does the cartoon competition benefit Wilders and his Freedom Party?
Stijn van Kessel: As far as Wilders is concerned, he seeks to generate attention by means of this contest. He is not truly interested in a cartoon contest but this is a way for him to generate media attention; he hopes that will eventually translate to votes.
And what a number of recent studies have shown is that when the media focuses on a certain number of themes, people will consider this theme to be more important.
So, in turn, that benefits parties that mobilise on the basis of this theme.
In an indirect way, media attention does create support. However, Wilders is not the only person focusing on these themes any more.
Al Jazeera: Is Wilders actually getting what he wants out of this then?
Van Kessel: That remains to be seen. Obviously, he is getting media attention, and that was probably his immediate goal.
However, you see that his star is waning somewhat, or he at least finds it hard to attain the attention he once did, partially because he has a competitor on the far-right, the Forum for Democracy (FvD).
Both parties, Wilders' Freedom Party and the FvD both attract culturally conservative voters, they both stress the issue of Islam, they're both eurosceptic.
However, FvD interestingly attracts also younger voters, it tries to appeal more to people who are higher educated.
So in that sense, you see that younger people vote for FvD, not for Wilders.
Al Jazeera: Do the competition and the protests play into each other's hands?
Van Kessel: I can't comment on the Pakistani part of the story because I know too little, but what is clear is that Wilders is doing this for domestic use.
What you see happening now, the protests in Pakistan, only helps him gain media attention in the Netherlands, thus becoming the centre of attention for his potential voters.
But Wilders seems a little bit over the hill, although I wouldn't count him out, but because there's so much political competition [on the right] I don't know if this will boost his support again.
Al Jazeera: How much of this is about religion and freedom of expression, and how much about gaining political prominence and power?
Van Kessel: Obviously I can't look into the head of Wilders, but this is simply a tactic to increase media attention.
If you're in the news, it gives emphasis to the issues and the parties, and he hopes that will increase public support for his political project.

Wednesday, August 29, 2018

Music Video - Bon Jovi - Livin' On A Prayer

Video Report - E-waste - the hazards of electronic waste in Africa | DW Documentary

Video Report - #Syria final showdown looming: What's the worst case scenario?

Video Report - 🇪🇺 🇺🇸 Can Europe live without the US? | Inside Story

Video Report - Violence, abuse and disappearances in #Bangladesh

'Opposite Sides': Pakistan, India Ex-Spy Chiefs Lift Lid On Deadly Rivalry



June 12, 2018
By Daud Khattak

Pakistan and India have fought four bloody wars since their creation in 1947, and continue to engage in daily clashes in the divided Himalayan region of Kashmir.
So for the former intelligence chiefs of the two nuclear-armed foes to co-author a book that sheds light on their efforts to outmaneuver each other would appear almost unthinkable.
Yet that is exactly what retired General Asad Durrani, head of Pakistan's Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) between 1990 and 1992, and his counterpart A.S. Dulat, who led India's Research and Analysis Wing (RAW) from 1999 to 2000, did.
Their book, Spy Chronicles: RAW, ISI, And The Illusion of Peace, is based on secret discussions held between the two former spy chiefs in hotels across Asia. Indian journalist Aditya Sinha organized and oversaw the effort, and put the results to paper.
In an exclusive interview with RFE/RL's Radio Mashaal, Dulat says "these are the perceptions of two people from opposite sides. Every word is as true as we know it to be."
The unprecedented book makes head-turning revelations about the conflict in Kashmir, Pakistan's covert role in the war in Afghanistan, and the U.S. raid that killed Al-Qaeda leader Osama bin Laden in Pakistan.
In India, the book has received a mostly positive reception, and Dulat has given televised interviews. But in Pakistan, Durrani's claims -- often in conflict with the official line -- have been widely criticized. He has been summoned by the military to explain himself. He has also been forbidden from leaving the country.
Below are the book's most eyebrow-raising revelations:
Pakistan's Complicity In Bin Laden Raid
In 2011, a team of American Navy SEALs flew into Pakistani territory from Afghanistan and killed bin Laden inside the secret compound in the northern Pakistani city of Abbottabad where he had hid for nearly a decade. Pakistan insisted it only knew of the U.S. operation after the team that carried out the raid had left the country.
"At some stage the ISI probably learnt about it [the compound] and he was handed over to the U.S. according to a mutually agreed process," Durrani suggested in the book, a scenario that would contradict Islamabad's official line.
"Perhaps we are the ones who told the Americans…we are going to feign ignorance," added Durrani, going on to speculate why the government denied prior knowledge of the raid. "If we denied any role, it may have been to avoid political fallout. Cooperating with the U.S. to eliminate a person regarded by many in Pakistan as a 'hero' could have embarrassed the government."
"For Pakistan, being blamed for incompetence was more acceptable than complicity," he wrote. "How could it not know [about] the U.S. helicopters ingressing 150 kilometers inside the country?"
Following the raid, Islamabad accused Pakistani doctor Shakil Afridi of running a fake vaccination campaign that he used to collect DNA samples from bin Laden family members to help the CIA track him down. Afridi has not been charged over those allegations.
But Durrani wrote that Afridi was not the only person to have discovered bin Laden's whereabouts.
"I have no doubt that a retired Pakistani officer who was in intelligence walked in and told the Americans," wrote Durrani, suggesting that the officer received part, if not all, of the United States' $25 million reward for information leading to bin Laden's capture or death.
Dulat wrote in the book that India's assessment "is the same. That he [bin Laden] was handed over by Pakistan."
In an interview with RFE/RL this month, Dulat expounds on his comments, alleging that "Pakistan was harboring Osama and the Pakistanis knew where he was and I think the Americans somehow got wind of this and they told the Pakistanis that 'look, we know where he is,' and then [said] to 'stay out of it.' Maybe there was a CIA mole in Pakistan, and General Durrani has also hinted at that."
Pakistani Support For Afghan Taliban
Afghanistan, the United States, and India have long accused Pakistan of providing safe havens to the Afghan Taliban on Pakistani territory, and of failing to go after the militants, claims Islamabad has consistently rejected.
Yet in 2016, Sartaj Aziz, a top foreign affairs adviser for Pakistan's government, admitted publicly for the first time that Islamabad has considerable influence over the Taliban because its "leadership is in Pakistan."
In 2015, former military dictator Pervez Musharraf revealed that there were Pakistani-backed militant "proxies" in Afghanistan.
In the book, Durrani added more weight to the widely held belief that Islamabad turns a blind eye to the Afghan Taliban's presence in Pakistan.
"[By] going against them, we would not only turn some more of our own people against us, but also these groups who have never harmed us," he wrote.
Durrani wrote that, after the U.S.-led invasion toppled the Taliban regime in 2001, "Pakistan did try to help with whatever was possible despite the pressure" from the international community to cut ties with the militant group, which Islamabad had recognized and supported during the group's rule from 1996 to 2001. "To lose that capital would be something from which you may not recover," he wrote.
India has been a key ally of the Afghan government and spent billions in infrastructure projects. Pakistan has also accused New Delhi of trying to encircle it by expanding its activities and influence in Kabul.
Speaking to RFE/RL, Dulat says New Delhi understands that "Pakistan has more stakes in Afghanistan" but that "India cannot be wished away from Afghanistan."
Dulat also says New Delhi has "banked too much on the Americans" in Afghanistan and should play a bigger role in the peace process. "I don't know if [India] is talking to the Taliban but I am very clear we should be talking to the Taliban. If we are engaged with the Taliban, very good. If we are not, I think it is high time that we did engage."
Pakistan's Support For Kashmiri Rebels
India and Pakistan have fought two wars over the divided Himalayan region of Kashmir, which both countries claim.
Rebels in the majority-Muslim region have been fighting Indian rule since 1989. India accuses Pakistan of arming and training anti-India rebels. Pakistan denies this, saying it offers only moral and diplomatic support to the militants and to Kashmiris who oppose Indian rule.
Nearly 70,000 people have been killed in the uprising and the ensuing Indian military crackdown.
"When the Kashmir uprising happened we did not know how far it would go," Durrani wrote. "We didn't want it to go out of control, which would lead to a war that neither side wanted…. ISI's leverage on the Kashmir insurgency turned out less than successful."
Durrani also suggested that Pakistan created the All Parties Hurriyat (Freedom) Conference, the main alliance of separatists in Indian-controlled Kashmir, to peddle its agenda in the region.
"Going back to the evolution of the Kashmir uprising of the 1990s, I think the formation of the Hurriyat to provide a political direction to the resistance was a good idea," he wrote. "Giving up handle on the movement -- letting the factions do what they bloody well wanted to -- was not."
Most Kashmiris support the rebel cause while also participating in civilian street protests against Indian control. New Delhi has been accused of ruthlessly cracking down on the demonstrators.
"Sometimes [the situation in Kashmir] gets so bad that there comes a state of hopelessness," Dulat tells RFE/RL. "Engagement is the key to the Kashmir solution. But we have not engaged them sufficiently."
South-Asian Union?
Perhaps Durrani's most eyebrow-raising suggestion for peace is the reunification of the subcontinent into a confederation like the European Union.
Pakistan and India were carved out from British India that was partitioned in 1947, creating a Muslim-majority Pakistan and Hindu-majority India.
"We can consider moving to a confederation, and then to a united India," wrote Durrani, in remarks that have riled hard-line conservatives on each side of the divide.
"Right now it's impossible to create a coalition or a union like the European Union, whose relevance is itself in doubt, but at some stage we can think of a common currency, or laws applicable to when we develop the new South Asian Union: a Confederation of South Asia," he wrote. "Delhi as the capital of a Union. Armed forces integrated. Reduction of forces numbers by ratio."

Imran Khan’s Victory Puts Minorities in Pakistan on ‘Red Alert’









After Pakistan’s cricket hero-turned-politician Imran Khan claimed victory in July in the country’s tense general election, Pakistani religious minority groups started bracing for a fight. 

After Pakistan’s cricket hero-turned-politician Imran Khan claimed victory in July in the country’s tense general election, Pakistani religious minority groups started bracing for a fight.
Many left-leaning Pakistani political observers and critics have compared Khan to U.S. President Donald Trump.
“There are many parallels that one can draw between Imran Khan’s pandering to the religious right and Donald Trump’s pandering to xenophobic groups in the United States,” Nida Kirmani, a sociologist, professor, and political observer based in Pakistan’s Lahore, told The Globe Post. “Both leaders earlier took more liberal positions, but later shifted to the right as a means of gaining power.”
One of the key points Khan campaigned on, particularly over the past few years, was in defense of the blasphemy law in Pakistan, an often rallying point for the country’s most religiously conservative base.
A study by Minority Rights Group International on religious minorities in Pakistan criticized the blasphemy law, for which penalties range from a fine to a death sentence, for primarily being used to “persecute religious minorities or to settle personal vendettas,” but any calls for change in the blasphemy laws have been strongly resisted by Islamic parties.
During one of his last rallies leading to the election on July 25, Imran Khan reminded his supporters that his political party, Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI), would irrevocably defend the law.
“It’s very worrying that Imran Khan and other politicians have expressed support for the blasphemy laws during this election period,” Omar Waraich, Deputy Director of South Asia, Amnesty International, told The Globe Post. “The laws are vaguely worded and coercive, having a disproportionate impact on religious minorities.”
At least 1,472 people were charged under Pakistan’s blasphemy laws between 1987 and 2016, according to statistics collected by the Center for Social Justice, a Pakistan-based advocacy group.
“Often, on the basis of little or no evidence, the accused face charges they cannot effectively defend themselves against,” Waraich added. “The new Pakistani government should amend or repeal all discriminatory laws.”
Ahmadis, who identify as Muslims and consider Ahmadiyya a sect of Islam, particularly face the brunt of religious discrimination and persecution.
“Although Khan’s manifesto states he will protect rights of religious minorities in Pakistan, his campaign rhetoric suggests otherwise,” Kashif N. Chaudhry, an advocate against Ahmadiyya persecution, told The Globe Post. “Imran Khan has employed toxic sectarian and anti-Ahmadi rhetoric to woo the far right during his election campaign.”
Pakistan’s constitution prohibits Ahmadis from identifying as Muslims. An anti-Ahmadiyya Ordinance XX issued in 1984 also prohibited the four million Ahmadis living in the country from “posing as a Muslim” with a penalty of up to three years in prison.
Leading up to the elections, Khan has attended several conferences where demands to place further restrictions on civil rights of Ahmadi Muslims were made.
“No political party has come out in condemnation of the anti-Ahmadi laws of Pakistan,” Kashif said. “However, no major party leader has utilized such blatant hate speech during their campaigning as Khan has.”
Activists are currently uncertain of how much of Khan’s gradual shift to the right for political opportunism will trickle down into policies established by the government.
“The worst case scenario is that he will let these [extremist] allies a free hand to hurt Pakistan’s religious minorities even more, either by turning a blind eye to their violence or tighten legislation against religious freedom,” Kashif added. “It is yet to be seen what posture he adopts towards his extremist allies, but religious minorities will definitely be on alert in the first few months of his regime.”
A university student and activist based in Karachi stated that the overall climate of the country leaves little room for being actively vocal against religious intolerance.
“Even criticism of the blasphemy law can be misinterpreted as blasphemy,” the activist, who wished to remain anonymous, explained to The Globe Post. “There isn’t much you can do about it on major platforms but that’s not to say there aren’t isolated movements on smaller scales that are taking a stand against intolerance and hate.”
One of the most recognized of these movements was lead by Jibran Nasir, a secular activist and human rights lawyer from Karachi, who ran as an independent candidate for a seat in the National Assembly of Pakistan and a Provincial Assembly this election.
“He didn’t win but he has started a public conversation that speaks up against anti-Ahmadi rhetoric, religious tolerance, and inclusion,” the activist explained. “And people are taking him seriously enough for those who have been campaigning on hate for decades to consider him a threat.”
Nasir was asked to declare his religion at a public forum while campaigning and he denied to answer on the principle that it was not relevant. At one point during the campaigning, he was met with a mob who demanded he refutes Ahmadis and then proceeded to rip his posters.
Nasir has since launched his own political party, Aam Awaam Movement. According to a public statement, one of the party’s core principles is to stand against extremist propaganda and focus on solving problems faced by the public.
“I don’t know if such a progressive agenda will win mainstream votes anytime soon but its a start,” the activist added. “Once, people realize that the common enemy is poverty and corruption and not religious differences, we will be able to move the country to a better place.”
A number of candidates from minority backgrounds did win provincial seats and Mahesh Malani became the first Hindu and non-Muslim to win a seat in the national assembly. Dawn, a Pakistani daily newspaper, cited an official document to report that Non-Muslim voters registered in the country have increased by 30 percent since the last elections.
When comparing Imran Khan rhetoric to President Donald Trump’s, Kirmani looked for the silver lining.
“In the United States, this has led to the emboldening of racist groups, but it has also encouraged a progressive movement of resistance,” she said. “One can see a similar trend possibly emerging in Pakistan.”

Pakistan–Russia Ties Reaching New Heights Under President Putin – OpEd



By Venita Christopher

For the last few decades President Putin has been warm to Pakistan which has led to increased expectations from Pakistan. The bilateral ties have witnessed many ups and downs however the recent positive trending relations between Russia and Pakistan is quite a new phenomenon. A number of significant changes have been seen in the foreign policy of both states which finally reached a level of joint collaboration for the stability in South Asia. Russia has special place in the foreign policy of Pakistan therefore the relations between both states are steadily growing.
A few days back a visible shift has been seen, both states stepped forward to sign Memorandum of Understanding on the recent visit in August of Pakistan’s chief of naval staff Vice admiral Kaleem Shaukat to Russia. Both states enthusiastically showed their responses over the naval collaboration and security environment and concluded to carry out wide range of joint military exercises in Pakistan along with the training of armed personals in navy. However, the naval cooperation of both states has led to a new diplomatic venture which might compel India to intervene and cause hurdles in the way.
Significant initiatives have been taken by President Putin to revive its state policy towards Pakistan soon after his fourth turn this year on May 7. Pakistan also showed an immediate response to the Russian leader with great optimism to work as close partners. Both states showed positive act, leaving behind past bitterness, grudges and stepped towards the new phase of their relationship.
According to Russian incentives Pakistan is a huge economic market that would further revive its economic and defense policy in future. Currently Pakistan is also trying to find ways to further strengthen its relations with Russia, therefore the negotiations over the purchase of Russian SU-35 fighter jets are going on between them along with Pakistan’s desire to buy T-90 tanks from Russia as part of already concerned long term deal between both states.
Moreover the Shanghai Cooperation Organization seems influential in connecting all regional states; a useful forum for mutual benefit as is evident from the exercise of “Peace Mission 2018” introduced by Russia under the agreement of SCO to conduct anti terrorist activities in different parts of South Asian region.
Ambassador of Russian Federation H.E. Alexy Y. Dedov to Pakistan conveyed message of President Putin to newly apointed Prime Minister Imran Khan that Pakistan should improve its economic relations as well as people to people contact, cultural exchange and educational trips between both states. In order to foster ties in coming future, President Putin should also plan and try to visit Pakistan.
Russia-Pakistan has collectively same objectives regarding the peace of South Asian region and moreover the diplomatic stance on containing terrorism from Afghanistan and over the US decision to abandon its nuclear deal with Iran.
Leaving the bitterness of the Cold War behind, both states have converging interests in Afghanistan and are collaboratively working on the peace mission to overcome the threats of ISIS. The multi-dimensional ties of both states can further be enhanced by providing incentives to the Russian companies for the economic investments in energy sector of Pakistan. Russia under the leadership of President Putin has further revived the terms by signing military cooperation pact with Pakistan, delivery of Russian helicopters, training to Pakistani officers at Russian institutes and mainly the new turning point is the Russian language radio service with broadcasting to be introduced in Pakistan.
Looking back at the whole scenario of past relations of Russia-Pakistan, one can easily say that there is no true friend and enemy in geopolitics. As China has also shown its interests in coming closer to Russia, India will face a visible defeat if Russia-Pakistan and China make an alliance. Soon a turning shift will likely to happen after Iran has shown its will to join the alliance of Russia-Pakistan and China which is a threatening alarm for India.

#Pakistan - Food insecurity in #Balochistan



By: Sana Samad  
It has been long time that Balochistan is suffering from food insecurity problem. The Sustainable Development Policy Institute (SDPI) provided a data which estimates that 30 out of 32 districts of the province are food insecure which has been alarming issue. Shockingly, only two districts including Quetta and Jaffarabad have food security in the entire province. Most of the districts are depended on agriculture and it is the only source for the food, but this sector is completely destroyed due to shortage of water.

According to the experts, over 80 percent of the agriculture is depended on rain fed, but there has been less rain in last few year as it is required. The other problem is that there is lack of dam and rain water is completely being wasted just due to bad management. In only Khuzdar district 350,000 cusecs of water are dumped through rivers in Arabian sea.
 In recent years, not a single large dam has been built in Balochistan to save the rain water for the agriculture due to which water table is falling sharply. The agriculture land is depended on water supplied by the tube wells which requires electricity. But the rural areas of the province just get  5 to 6 hours electricity in a day, so how they can maintain the agriculture land. This is the only reason that the problem of food insecurity is increasing rapidly in the province.
The drought is affected the people and the livestock. The most dangerous drought in Balochistan occurred during the period of 1997 to 2005. This killed over 1.76 million cattle and an area of 0.798 million hectares were wasted which became the loss of 25 billion. The problem can be more dangerous as the effect of drought can be much greater due to the increasing population and lack of attention from the government side.
Government is also the responsible of food insecurity then why government is silent and not paying any attention to resolve this ongoing problem. The former Chief Minister of Balochistan Dr Abdul Malik declared a package of 1 billion to be utilized for the drought victims. But since that not a single rupee has been spent on them. These things raised questions, where these funds are going? Why these funds are not being given to the poor people? Till when they should suffer from these problems? Unless the government will not be serious about this alarming issue nothing can be done and the drought victim will fever feel protection and they will continue to suffer from food insecurity.

#PAKISTANI JOURNALISTS UNDER THREAT FROM DEOBANDI TERRORISTS: HRW

The Asia Director of the Human Rights Watch, Brad Adams, has said that a climate of fear has impeded media coverage of abuses both by government security forces and militant groups due to which journalists increasingly practice self-censorship after numerous attacks by militant groups, including the Taliban, in retaliation for criticism, particularly around their extremist diktats.

In a letter to Prime Minister Imran Khan, HRW’s Adams further said that media outlets remain under pressure from the authorities to avoid reporting on several issues, including criticism of government institutions and the judiciary.
“The PTI has been a strong proponent of free expression, including on social media, to criticise state policy and press for change. An independent media is key to robust dialogue that reflects public concerns. Human Rights Watch hopes that the PTI government will foster a culture of political tolerance for media criticism,” the HRW said.
The HRW Asia Director urged the Pakistan government to take concrete steps to protect fundamental civil, political, economic, social, and cultural rights. It demanded ensuring freedom of expression/stop attacks on civil society; freedom of religion and belief; violence against women and girls; access to education; restoring moratorium on death penalty; and terrorism and counterterrorism abuses.
“Imran Khan has an important opportunity to create a rights-respecting government that abides by the rule of law and restores the public faith in democratic institutions. It is crucial for Pakistan’s development for the government to actively carry out human rights agenda,” the rights watchdog said.

http://www.shiitenews.org/index.php/pakistan/item/35410-pakistani-journalists-under-threat-from-deobandi-terrorists-hrw