Friday, January 19, 2018

#Pakistan - #JusticeForZainab - A MURDER OF THE MIND

By Arif Ali—AFP


ANGER AND DESPAIR ARE NOT CONDUCIVE TO FINDING EFFECTIVE CURES FOR SOCIETY’S ILLS
The raped body of 7-year-old Zainab, found dumped in a rubbish heap in Kasur on Jan. 11, has had a traumatic effect on Pakistan. There are a number of aspects to this trauma that must be analyzed before a cure is put together.
The first devastating effect is despair. The details of the rape-murder tend to switch off the normal problem-solving capacity of the collective mind. There is an upsurge of anger, which promises a radical and conclusive “solution” under the current conditions of justice. Because of the “unfamiliar” details of the crime, what dominates is not so much anger as despair, which is not a good collective feeling for problem-solving.
Passive despair triggers another reaction: self-hatred. At the collective level it means a serious blow to the normal levels of self-approval keeping the collective identity intact to get rid of the problem. Self-hatred also tends to isolate the individual and alienate him from the socio-political conditions he lives under. It also constitutes a break with the democratic political order leading to submission to a non-democratic one.
The flawed administration of the state that allowed the tragedy of little Zainab to unfold triggers the rage for change, as if the pulling down of the government would lead to radical overnight improvement. Political parties, sensing the collective mood, propose violent solutions and are able to get the support of the gravely offended citizen. This is the phase where the despairing and self-hating citizen succumbs to violence.

In Kasur, powerful men and their families have adopted abnormal ways of expressing their dominance. The ruling party makes concessions to them because of their support to its leaders. The outraged citizen in his despair supports the pulling down of the government with violent politics. The state is thus destabilized, leading to a further undermining of its capacity to apply solutions to prevent children from being violated with impunity.

http://newsweekpakistan.com/a-murder-of-the-mind/

'We believe Hafiz Saeed should be prosecuted, we've made that very clear to Pakistan,' says US

The US firmly believes Pakistan needs to prosecute terrorist Hafiz Saeed and it has made this "very clear" to Islamabad, which recently said there is no case against 26/11 Mumbai terror mastermind.
A US state department spokeswoman today reiterated and underlined Washington's view on Saeed, saying she's aware that Pakistan's prime minister said two days ago that Saeed can't be prosecuted+ because there is no case against him. "We have made our points and our concerns to the Pakistani Government very clear. We believe that this individual should be prosecuted.... We believe that he should be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law," said Heather Nauert, a spokeswoman at the US State Department. Two days ago, Pakistan's prime minister Shahid Khaqan Abbasi referred to Saeed as 'sahib', or 'sir', and said there is no case against him in Pakistan, therefore no action can be taken against him. However, earlier in the month, Pakistan's interior ministry 'blacklisted' Saeed and his group the Jamaat-ud-Dawa (JuD).
Pakistan may be confused about Saeed, but the US is not. To make it very clear what Washington's view is, Nauert further said todat the US regards Saeed a terrorist and part of a foreign terror group. The US has a $10 million reward for information on Saeed. "He was the mastermind, we believe, of the 2008 Mumbai attacks which killed many people, including Americans as well," said Nauert of Saeed. Not only the US, the United Nations (UN) too considers him a terrorist, Nauert said. And the Lashkar-e-Toiba (LeT), a terror group Saeed's affiliated too, is also designated a foreign terror organisation by the UN.
"He (Saeed) is listed by the UN Security Council 1267, the al-Qaida Sanctions Committee for targeted sanctions due to his affiliation with Lashkar-e Taiba, which is a designated foreign terror organization. So, I just want to remind people of that, of who this individual is, and make it clear that we have addressed our concerns with the Pakistani Government," said Nauert.
https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/world/pakistan/we-believe-hafiz-saeed-should-be-prosecuted-weve-made-that-very-clear-to-pakistan-says-us/articleshow/62563905.cms

Pakistan Orders Closure Of RFE/RL's Bureau In Islamabad

Pakistan’s Interior Ministry has ordered the closure of the offices of RFE/RL's Radio Mashaal in Islamabad after Pakistan’s Inter-Service Intelligence (ISI) agency accused the broadcaster of airing programs “against the interest of Pakistan” and “in line with [a] hostile intelligence agency’s agenda.”
The director of Radio Mashaal, Mohammad Amin Mudaqiq, said Interior Ministry officers arrived at the broadcaster’s Islamabad bureau on January 19 and were meeting with the bureau chief and administrator to discuss the closure order.
The ministry’s order accused Radio Mashaal of “portraying Pakistan [as] a hub of terrorism and [a] safe haven for different militant groups.”
The closure order received by RFE/RL's Radio Mashaal
The closure order received by RFE/RL's Radio Mashaal
It said Radio Mashaal programming presented Pakistan as a “failed state in terms of providing security to its people,” in particular minorities and ethnic Pashtuns.
It said Radio Mashaal showed ethnic Pashtuns in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Province, Balochistan Province, and the Federally Administered Tribal Areas (FATA) along the border with Afghanistan as “disenchanted with the state.”
It also accused the broadcaster of “distorting facts [to] incite the target population against the state and its institutions.”
RFE/RL President Thomas Kent said he was “extraordinarily concerned by the closure” and was “urgently seeking more information about the Pakistani authorities’ intentions.”
Kent said Radio Mashaal, which broadcasts from Prague and has both radio and digital operations, is a “private news organization supported by the U.S. Congress with no connection to the intelligence agencies of any country.”
“Radio Mashaal is an essential source of reliable, balanced information for our Pakistani audience,” Kent said. “We hope this situation will be resolved without delay.”
The closure order was issued after Pakistan’s chief of army staff, General Qamar Javed Bajwa, said on January 12 that Pakistan feels “betrayed” by U.S. criticism that it is not doing enough to fight terrorism and by Washington’s decision to suspend military aid for Islamabad.
U.S. President Donald Trump on January 1 accused Pakistan of "lies and deceit" and said the United States would suspend up to $1.9 billion a year in military aid until Islamabad moves decisively against Afghan Taliban fighters and Haqqani network militants who he said have found safe haven within Pakistan's borders.

What Russia’s Changing Role in South Asia Means for Pakistan

Pakistan - Better security for anti-polio workers


Yet another polio team has come under attack.
On Thursday, two anti-polio workers were shot and killed by unidentified attackers in Quetta.
Anti-polio workers across the country have been continuously attacked by militants to impede vaccination drives. Last year in November, members of a polio team were beaten up in Multan. In October, those looking after a polio team’s security were attacked in Bajaur Agency. Three levy personnel died in the attack.
Stricter security measures need to be ensured for protection of anti-polio teams across the country.
The incident that took place in Quetta must be interrogated to track down those responsible for the attack. Lip service alone will no longer do if we want the campaign against the Polio virus to succeed in all parts of the country. Claims regarding security measures were made by the authorities in the past as well but they were not followed by action.
For effective security arrangements, the authorities will need to take the public on board as well, especially in remote areas. Electronic and print media campaigns could be considered for the purpose, but most importantly, the officials need to reach out to communities through elected leaders and civil society networks. The public needs to be made aware of the harms of the disease and the necessity of vaccination. The public at large must also be informed about the international isolation that the country stands to face if it cannot eliminate the virus completely this year.
Once the public has full trust and confidence in the efficacy of the anti-polio campaign, it will be easier for the authorities to launch immunisation drives. With the public on their side, the authorities will also be able to identify miscreants and proceed against them effectively.

Pakistan - Disrespecting The Parliament




The tirade of Sheikh Rasheed and PTI Chairman Imran Khan against the sitting parliament of Pakistan is not only extremely irresponsible but also a below the belt strike on the institutions of this country, particularly the democratic principles that both claim to be champions of. Both politicians have been a part of the same parliament since the last four years and despite their denial, they were very much made the parliament and the character that they accuse it of having.
In the last four years, these same politicians have been enjoying the perks as members of the parliament, and they have drawn salaries as members of the parliament. This is a huge question mark on their judgement of the parliament. It took them four years, after enjoying the privileges of the tax payers money, to discern that the setup is not working. This very much makes this more of a political gimmick rather an accusation based on facts. Had they believed, in the last four years, that the parliament is what they claim it to be; as honest politicians they should have resigned there and then.
Another aspect which is to be considered here is that if the assumption is being made that the parliament was not able to deliver anything substantial and does not have people of merit sitting on those seats, then the democratic way to go about it - as members of the parliament - would have been to take part in the proceedings and push for betterment. However, in the case of Sheikh Rasheed and Imran Khan both, their absenteeism from the parliament is no secret at all. In fact, when the National Assembly (NA) rightfully adopted the resolution presented by Federal Minister Baleegh-ur-Rehman condemning Sheikh Rashid and Pakistan Imran Khan for openly cursing the parliament at a rally in Lahore, both of them were absent during the proceedings.
This goes to show their commitment towards upholding the democratic principles of the country and respecting the institutions that make up the core of the state. As politicians it is very important to understand that the system one aims to change can only be changed by respecting its institutions and following the patterns laid out by the laws of the country to work towards betterment.

Benazir Bhutto - There's only been one female head of government in modern history who gave birth while in office




By Joe Sterling

New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern isn't the first prime minister to expect a baby while in office.
A generation ago, Pakistani Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto was pregnant with, and gave birth, to her daughter Bakhtawar on January 25, 1990. At the time she'd been in office a little more than a year.
The first-ever female leader of a Muslim nation, Bhutto served as the prime minister of Pakistan from 1988 to 1990 and from 1993 to 1996. She was assassinated in 2007 during a political campaign
On Friday, Bakhtawar, who's now a trustee at the Shaheed Zulfikar Ali Bhutto Institute of Science and Technology, passed along her congrats to the New Zealand leader "on the wonderful news."

    Then and now

    Ardern said she would be taking six weeks leave following the baby's birth. Deputy Prime Minister Winston Peters would serve as acting prime minister during that time.
    "I am not the first woman to multi-task, I'm not the first woman to work and have a baby," she said. "I know these are special circumstances but there will be many women who will have done this well before I have."
    Benazir Bhutto with Rajiv Gandhi on her right in Paris on July 13, 1989.
    The challenges were far more daunting for Bhutto 27 years ago.
    She was apprehensive that her rivals, who wanted an interim government in place while she was having a baby, wanted to push her aside. She went to a Karachi hospital "incognito" and had Bakhtawar via a Caesarian section, according to London's Independent newspaper.
    "The next day I was back on the job, reading government papers and signing government files," she later wrote.
    "Only later did I learn that I was the only head of government in recorded history actually to give birth while in office. It was a defining moment, especially for young women, proving that a woman could work and have a baby in the highest and most challenging leadership positions."
    Bhutto had two other children. Her first child, Bilawal Bhutto Zardari, was born months before her 1988 election. Another daughter, Aseefa, was born in 1993. That was a couple of months before she took office for her second stint as prime minister.

    Bilawal Bhutto phones Munnu Bhai’s son; offers condolence

    Chairman Pakistan Peoples Party Bilawal Bhutto Zardari telephoned Kashif, son of renowned literary and journalism figure Munnu Bhai (late) and offered condolence on the sad demise of his father on Friday evening. Chairman PPP also paid tributes to Munnu Bhai for his great contribution in the fields of progressive literature and journalism during the conversation.

    http://www.thesindhtimes.com/pak/bilawal-bhutto-phones-munnu-bhais-son-offers-condolence/

    Bilawal Bhutto expressed deep grief and sorrow over sad demise of Munnu Bhai

    Chairman Pakistan Peoples Party Bilawal Bhutto Zardari has expressed deep grief and sorrow over the sad demise of Munnu Bhai.
    “So sad to hear Munnu Bhai has passed away. Pakistan loses another progressive voice of integrity & sanity,” wrote the PPP Chairman in his tweet this morning.
    In his condolence message, Bilawal Bhutto Zardari said that death of Munnu Bhai has created a vacuum in progressive literature and journalist, which can hardly be filled in many decades.
    Bilawal Bhutto Zardari prayed to Almighty Allah to rest the departed soul in eternal peace and grant courage and fortitude to the members of bereaved family to bear this irreparable loss.
    https://mediacellppp.wordpress.com/2018/01/19/bilawal-bhutto-expressed-deep-grief-and-sorrow-over-sad-demise-of-munnu-bhai/

    Thursday, January 18, 2018

    Music Video - Rita Ora - Anywhere

    Video Report - Republican Sen. Jeff Blake’s full speech, blasting Trump's press attacks, cites rhetoric of Stalin

    Video Report - Bernie Sanders Blasts Republicans' Cruel Budget Negotiation Tactics

    Video Report - With Mike Pence In Front Row, Pastor Rips Into Donald Trump | All In | MSNBC

    Video Report - #CNN - #Acosta: White House blocked reporter questions

    Video Report - Afghan president says country won't survive without US support

    Video Report - Friends vs Political Correctness: What happens to having a sense of humor in the age of PC?

    Video Report - If US government shuts down, you'll see ... - CNN

    Video Report - Stormy Daniels shared her story in 2011

    Video - Stormy Daniels: Sex With Trump Was 'Textbook Generic' - Late Show with Stephen Colbert

    #Pakistan - FOUR SHIA SOCIAL WORKERS OF QUETTA GO MISSING

    Four Shia Muslims belonging to a social welfare organization (NGO) have gone missing and close-aides believe that they were taken into undeclared and illegal custody and subjected to enforced disappearance.
    Those who have gone missing are identified as Amir Changezi, Mukhtar Hussaini, Changez Ali and Imran Ali. They are social workers and working for Noor Welfare Society in Quetta. They are closely related.
    Their relatives are also scared of the security agencies hence they are avoiding protest. However, women relatives have raised voice against their enforced disappearance. They have demanded that they should be produced in the court of law for trial if there is any case against them, otherwise they must be released forthwith.

    http://www.shiitenews.org/index.php/pakistan/item/32599-four-shia-social-workers-of-quetta-go-missing

    #Pakistan - Imran’s dangerous presser




    Democracy here in Pakistan has long been a game of numbers, if not thrones. And never more so than when elections are looming large. Indeed, our politicians often confuse crowd-pulling power with political prowess.
    This is as true today as it has ever been. The ruling PMLN has dismissed the joint opposition rally on Lahore’s Mall Road as failing to put people on seats. Which, of course, may not be a bad thing, given that this was held on the same day that the city’s High Court ran ads in the English press banning protests in that part of town. And even though the LHC made an exception in this instance — we would argue that an opposition seeking such special treatment from the judiciary risks allegations of orchestrated political opportunism. Be that as it may, we stand with the opposition parties as they demand justice for the PAT activists who were opened fire on by the Punjab police in the Model Town tragedy. That the Chief Minister is still standing almost four years on is a grave travesty.
    Yet where we hesitate in lending our support is to Imran Khan and his so-called explosive press conference. The PTI chief had promised to disclose details about the money laundering trail leading back to the deposed Nawaz Sharif. And he didn’t disappoint. Though even here we are uncomfortable with the presence of former party secretary general Jahangir Tareen, who has been banned for life from the National Assembly over failure to fully disclose his assets. Among Imran’s claims are that Nawaz money-laundered up to Rs 1.74 billion from just one of his private companies; part of an alleged 16-enterprise network. He also implicated elements of the Punjab police. Separate charges were reserved for Shehbaz Sharif. Yet it was only after dishing the dirt that the PTI leader made any mention of providing these details to the NAB and other state institutions for further investigation.
    And, for us, herein lies the rub.
    For we staunchly believe that Imran’s first priority ought to have been to hand such evidence over to the relevant authorities; including the Supreme Court. But what should not have happened was announcing all this to the media. If this was a vote-of-no-confidence in national institutions — this begs the question as to whether he trusts the latter to oversee the general elections. The answer is most probably not, given that he has not given up his cries of punctured tyres from the last time around. We are not calling for PTI or any of the other opposition parties to collectively boycott the upcoming polls. For this would be tantamount to openly inviting the Army to never return to the barracks. But we do call on the media to snub such spectacles which clearly jeopardise the tenets of free and fair inquiry. After all, the role of the fourth estate should remain one of opposition and impartial checks-and-balances.
    Where we do agree with Imran is that the Parliament has brought itself somewhat into disrepute. Particularly, with regard to passing the Election Reforms Bill 2017; which may or may not have been secured with votes-for-cash on the part of all the King’s men. Yet, sadly, we have been here before when then PM Gillani infamously said that his party would make a token fuss before Parliament about the ratcheted up US drone programme before forgetting about it. And, more recently, our lawmakers contested two by-elections on equal footing with the party of a globally proscribed terrorist. Indeed, the latter is set to personally contest the general polls.
    Sadly, if our politicians carry on like this — they will end up destroying this country’s long-term democratic health.

    PPP would never endorse disrespecting Parliament: Bilawal Bhutto


    Pakistan Peoples Party Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari on Wednesday said that his party would never endorse disrespecting Parliament.
    “The #PPP respects Parliament and will always respect Parliament,” Chairman Bilawal said in a tweet.
    “Cannot help the behaviour of others but will never endorse disrespecting Parliament,” he added.
    Separately, opposition leader also criticized Imran Khan for his offensive remarks about the parliament.
    “Imran Khan’s remarks show there is no difference between him and Nawaz Sharif,” he said, adding that the parliament cannot be blamed for a government’s failure.
    His remarks came shortly after Imran Khan, speaking at a protest rally jointly staged by opposition groups in Lahore, said he curses the parliament which has allowed a convicted person to become the head of a political party.

    #Pakistan - #PPP condemns women polio workers killing; demands immediate arrest of culprits

    Chairman Pakistan Peoples Party Bilawal Bhutto Zardari, Aseefa Bhutto Zardari and MNA Mehreen Bhutto have strongly condemned the barbaric killings of two women polio workers in Quetta on Wednesday.
    In a statement, the PPP Chairman said that entire nation was in a state of grief over the martyrdom of the innocent polio workers in Balochistan and demanded immediate arrest of the killers.
    Bilawal Bhutto Zardari said that nation salutes the health workers engaged in Jehad against the deadly disease and called upon the government for provided fool-proof security to the polio workers in entire country.
    In her Tweeter message  Aseefa Bhutto said, “Strongly condemn the attack on #polio workers in #Quetta ! The culprits must be brought to justice. I salute the brave workers who were heinously killed while trying to protect our children.”
    In an statement issued by Dr Mehreen Bhutto. general Secretary PPP Ladies Wing strongly condemned women polio workers killing in Quetta and demands immediate arrest of culprits.
    http://www.thesindhtimes.com/pak/ppp-condemns-women-polio-workers-killing-quetta-demands-immediate-arrest-culprits/

    Gunmen in #Pakistan kill women on #polio eradication mission



    Gunmen in Pakistan shot and killed two women working on a polio eradication campaign on Thursday, the latest in a string of attacks on efforts to protect children from the crippling and sometimes deadly disease.
    No group claimed responsibility for the killings in the southwestern city of Quetta but such attacks have in the past been carried out by Islamist militants, who oppose the immunization of children as un-Islamic.
    Sakina Bibi, 50, and her 20-year-old daughter, Alizah, were giving immunization drops to children when two gunmen riding on a motorcycle shot them, said police official Naseebullah Khan.
    “They died on their way to a hospital,” said Khan.
    The women were taking part in an immunization campaign in five districts of Baluchistan province, Khan said. Quetta is the provincial capital.
    Pakistan is one of only three countries in the world, along with Afghanistan and Nigeria, that suffers from endemic polio, a childhood virus that can cause paralysis or death.
    Efforts to eradicate the disease have been undermined by opposition from militants, who say immunization is a foreign ploy to sterilize Muslim children or a cover for Western spies.
    In 2015, a suicide bomber killed 15 people outside a vaccination center in Quetta in an attack claimed by the Pakistani Taliban and another militant group, Jundullah.
    Suspicion of immunization drives was compounded by the hunt for al Qaeda leader Osama bin Laden, architect of the 2001 attacks on the United States.
    A Pakistani doctor has been accused of using a fake vaccination campaign to collect DNA samples that the U.S. Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) was believed to have been using to try to track down bin Laden.
    Bin Laden was killed in a covert raid by U.S. special forces in 2011 in the Pakistani town of Abbottabad, where he had been hiding.
    Pakistan Prime Minister Shahid Khaqan Abbasi condemned the Thursday attack and ordered an investigation.
    “Polio teams are rendering a huge national service to save our children from the crippling disease. Attack on these dedicated workers, risking their lives for their nation, is an attack on our future,” Abbasi’s office said in a statement.
    In another attack on Thursday, unidentified gunmen killed two policemen on patrol in Quetta, police said.
    Baluchistan, a strategically important region bordering Iran as well as Afghanistan, is plagued by violence by Sunni Islamist sectarian groups linked to the Taliban, al Qaeda and Islamic State. It also has an indigenous ethnic Baloch insurgency fighting against the central government.

    Pakistan - #Pakistan - #JusticeForZainab - Self-righteous anger over Kasur




    By Dr Shenila Khoja-Moolji
    The horrific rape and murder of an eight-year-old Pakistani girl-child, Zainab, has galvanized all segments of society in Pakistan and the diaspora to publicly condemn violence against girls and women.
    There have been rallies where men and women have been protesting the lack of police efforts to catch Zainab’s murderer. On television, anchors have dedicated shows to sexual abuse and child abuse.
    Many see Zainab’s murder as an opportunity to discuss otherwise taboo issues. Education activists are calling for revising the school curricula to include information about sexual and child abuse. Others are calling for raising awareness among parents. Politicians and religious leaders have taken to the podium/social media to express their horror. It seems that the nation has awoken from a slumber — citizens are even meting out justice on the streets, beating up men accused of harassing girls and women.
    While well-intentioned, these calls responsibilise schools and parents without paying attention to the historic and systemic demeaning of Pakistani women. Rape and murder of girls do not happen in a vacuum. It is an effect of sedimented societal views about the female sex and institutional practices that reproduce male dominance, in every domain of life.
    We live in a society that abhors women — we don’t like it when they enter the workplace and make it known through harassment and unequal pay. We ogle them when they are on the streets and even grope them when the opportunity presents itself.
    We take away their already minuscule space in the mosques by building mosques without a women’s section. We are threatened when they appear as TV personalities and curse at them on air. We make jokes about rape and use cuss words with ‘mother’ and ‘sister’ in them.
    We create a political fuss when a girl with uncovered hair is depicted in a textbook. We pass laws like the Hudood Ordinance. We police what women can wear at universities. We even reprimand female professors for wearing jeans!
    We do all this and then wonder why eight-year-old girls get assaulted? Who is responsible for this monstrosity? YOU. You, my dear reader, and I, are complicit in reproducing a system that views women as sub-human. We reinforce male privilege through minor, everyday actions from swear words to advocating for policies that make life unbearable for women.
    If we are so angry about what happened to Zainab, then it behooves us to first check ourselves and our views about women and girls. We then have to come out and try to hold societal institutions — from the state and the media to the mosque — accountable for portraying women as less-than-men.
    Indeed, in Pakistan, women are not considered as fully human. They are viewed as sex objects available for men’s pleasure, as upholders of familial morality and honour, or as domestic managers who will nurture children. Women who deviate from these pre-assigned roles do not have much breathing room. If men are so mad at Zainab’s murder then let’s see them give up their privilege and make space for women in their professions, on the streets, in media and in politics. Let’s see them pass pro-women laws or just implement the laws already in place. Let’s see them stand up and speak for women when misogynist elements want to push women to the margins every day.
    Call me cynical but this sudden righteous anger of politicians, religious reformers, and men at large means nothing if it is just going to devolve into a PR stunt. If we don’t reform our institutions, if we don’t reform ourselves, we cannot be surprised if there are more Zainabs, unfortunately.

    #Pakistan - THE abduction, rape and murder of little Zainab - Child protection




    Muhammad Ahmad Pansota




    THE abduction, rape and murder of little Zainab has not only robbed one family of a child but has also ravaged this country. She was not the first child we failed to protect.
    Child abuse, particularly sexual violence, is one of the most pressing social issues facing our nation. Such crimes are tragic reminders of the failure of the state, and call for a complete overhaul of our intent towards child protection.
    The majority of the child abuse cases in Pakistan are registered under the Zina Ordinance, 1979, which prohibits all forms of illegal sexual intercourse including rape. The Punjab Suppression of Prostitution Ordinance, 1961, the Sindh Children Act, 1955, and the Punjab Children Ordinance, 1983, all cover some forms of child abuse.
    In 1990, Pakistan ratified the UN Conven­tion on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC), committing itself to implement the convention’s provisions through harmonised policies, legislation and plans of action, and to report progress to the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child every five years.
    After revelations of a child pornography ring in Kasur in 2015, 20 people were arrested in connection with the criminal scandal. At the time, only rape and sodomy were punishable under the law. As a result, several new provisions were added to our legislature to strengthen our child protection framework.
    Let little Zainab be the last child we fail as a state.
    The first amendment to the Pakistan Penal Code in relation to child abuse in 2016 criminalised sexual assault against minors, child pornography and trafficking. Sexual assault is now punishable by up to seven years in prison (previously, only rape was criminalised), and child pornography (previously not included in the law) is punishable by seven years in prison and a fine of Rs700,000.
    Prosecution for rape has also benefited from recent amendments. Sections 164(A) and 164(B), inserted into the Code of Criminal Procedure in 2016, enable authorities to obtain and use DNA evidence. Section 161(A) also guarantees a rape victim the right to legal representation.
    Despite a complex framework, the legislative tools we have at our disposal have not been utilised effectively, and have thus far failed to deter perpetrators of violence against children. While further specialised legislation is needed, as the situation stands, our biggest failure in protecting our children is not lack of legislation but lack of its enforcement.
    The depravity that leads to such crimes occurring, especially considering the circumstances of Zainab’s case, calls for further action. The preamble to the Anti-Terrorism Act, 1997, introduces the act “to provide for the prevention of terrorism, sectarian violence and for speedy trial of heinous offences”. Based on these goals, it is high time that rape and sexual violence against children were added to Section 6 of the ATA so that it may be prosecuted with the same vigilance given to perpetrators of acts of terror.The DNA profile of all citizens should be included in the Nadra database.
    It is also necessary to properly train judicial officials and law-enforcement agencies. According to Human Rights Watch, “Even a well-drafted law is unlikely to achieve its objectives in the absence of a trained and accountable police force, adequately staffed probation departments, judges that are familiar with the applicable domestic law and international standards, and facilities that are designed for the guidance and care of juvenile offenders.”
    The juvenile justice system also requires attention.
    The age defining a child should be brought up in accordance to what is prescribed internationally. Secondly, there should be equal treatment for children regardless of gender — as for zina crimes, female victims should no longer be punished for an abuse inflicted upon them. Thirdly, there should be stricter punishment against perpetrators of sexual violence against children. And, as per Article 39 of the UNCRC, the government should take all necessary measures to promote the psychological and physical recovery of child victims. Currently, rehabilitative measures are underdeveloped, if not non-existent. There is an urgent need to establish such facilities throughout the country.
    There must be an overhaul of the system at every level so that the authorities are not only successful in recovering children, but also in catching and punishing culprits. The crimes against Zainab reflect the absolute failure of the police, expose the lack of foresight in our legislature, and have resulted in the public losing all faith in this government.
    If we wait much longer to effect concrete change, we will also lose faith in ourselves. The fate of young Zainab, loving daughter, thoughtful sister, cherished granddaughter, passionate student — human being — should be etched in our collective conscience. Let her be the last child we fail as a state.