Saturday, February 21, 2015

Q. and A.: Barnett Rubin on China’s Role in Afghanistan







In recent months, China has made pronouncements that reveal it is willing, perhaps even eager, to grow its engagement with troubled Afghanistan, whose remote Wakhan Corridor abuts China’s western border. On Feb. 12, while visiting Pakistan, Foreign Minister Wang Yi reiterated China’s desire to play a “constructive role” in a hypothetical peace process.
“We will support the Afghan government in realizing reconciliation with various political factions including the Taliban,” Mr. Wang told reporters in Islamabad, according to Reuters.
That follows on other initial attempts China has made to feel out the political landscape there. Late last year, two Afghan Taliban officials traveled with Pakistani officials to Beijing to discuss a potential peace process. In London in December, China, the United States and Afghanistan held a first trilateral meeting to discuss the Afghan future. Present at the meeting was Sun Yuxi, China’s special envoy to Afghanistan.
Any sign of China’s potentially becoming a regional peacemaker is welcome news for the Obama administration, which has supported political reconciliation in Afghanistan. At the center of promoting United States-China dialogue on Afghanistan is Barnett Rubin, a veteran Afghanistan scholar who served for four and a half years as a senior adviser to the American government’s special representative for Afghanistan and Pakistan. He was hired for that position in 2009 by Richard C. Holbrooke, the first special envoy, and worked with two of Mr. Holbrooke’s successors after his death in 2010. Since the summer of 2012, Mr. Rubin, who is also part of the Center on International Cooperation at New York University, has helped to organize seven meetings on Afghanistan that make up a “track two” dialogue between American and Chinese parties.
He recently shared his thoughts with The New York Times on China’s growing engagement with Afghan politics, what the United States would like to see result from that relationship and China’s concerns over rising Uighur militancy along its western frontier.
Q. As the United States draws down its combat troops in Afghanistan, what kind of role would it like to see China play in the country?
A.
While the U.S. is ending its combat role in Afghanistan, we and our allies have pledged a continuing commitment to Afghanistan for at least a decade. So there is no question of China filling any “vacuum” left by the U.S., as people sometimes say. Rather there is a need for China to become a partner of the U.S. in its extensive non­combat roles.
Ultimately, the stability of Afghanistan, a land­locked country in Asia, will depend on its neighbors agreeing to make it a center of cooperation rather than conflict. China is Afghanistan’s largest neighbor and has the world’s second-largest economy. The U.S. hopes that China will become a full-fledged partner in international efforts to support and stabilize Afghanistan.
Afghan President Ashraf Ghani has also asked that the U.S. and China make Afghanistan into the best example of their cooperation. China is unlikely to provide large amounts of financial assistance, but it has announced plans for a number of large regional economic initiatives, including the Silk Road Economic Belt (both overland and maritime) and the Pakistan Economic Corridor. The U.S. is also supporting major investment in regional economic integration under the name of the New Silk Road Project. These programs can complement each other in creating an economic incentive to cooperation around and in Afghanistan that has not existed before.
Plus China has a unique relationship with Pakistan. U.N. Special Representative of the Secretary­ General Lakhdar Brahimi used to say, “Afghanistan cannot be stable unless Pakistan wants it to be stable,” and it is still true, but there is immense distrust between the two. Pakistan and Afghanistan both trust China, insofar as the word trust has any application in international affairs, and Chinese and U.S. interests are largely convergent in the region. Therefore, a process of cooperation among these four countries provides the best hope of persuading Pakistan it can achieve legitimate national objectives without the use of militant proxy forces that could ultimately destroy Pakistan itself.
India, Iran and Russia have reservations about such a process, for fear of being marginalized. China is in a better position than the U.S. to reassure Iran and Russia, and the U.S. can work with both India and China to assure that all have a share in regional development and that anti­terror efforts target anti­-Indian groups as well. I have been encouraged by the efforts of senior Chinese diplomats to engage India and Russia and persuade them that China wants to help support regional security and create economic structures that will be of benefit to both countries.
Q. How willing is China to engage in the politics of Afghanistan? What are its main motivations for getting involved in the internal politics there? What signs of wariness do you detect?
A. The Chinese emphasize that “non­interference” in the internal politics of other countries is a pillar of their foreign policy. China will support Afghan efforts to bring the Taliban and others fighting the current international presence and the government into the political system to provide the regional stability needed for cooperation on counter­terrorism and economic growth. But it will do so mainly by cooperation with the governments of Pakistan, Afghanistan and the U.S., not by becoming involved with Afghanistan’s domestic politics. From what I have seen, China has neither the goal nor the ability to become involved in internal Afghan politics. Chinese have less personal contact and weaker personal relationships with Afghan political actors than officials and others from the U.S., Pakistan, Iran, Russia or India. They are reluctant to deploy people on the ground. Their risk­-averse operational doctrines may have to change if they believe that their interests will require deeper involvement than heretofore.
Q. Is China growing its investments in Afghanistan? The Aynak copper mine appeared in many news stories in recent years, but it has not had much success as a business venture.
A. Virtually all foreign investments in Afghanistan, including the Chinese investment in the Aynak copper mine, are stalled by insecurity and uncertainty over the future. At this point, contrary to some outdated impressions, China is not primarily interested in Afghanistan for its natural resources. It is prepared to wait until investments can become genuinely profitable. China’s main motivations are denying sanctuary to terrorist and separatist groups that target China and creating a stable regional environment to encourage investment, especially in interior and western China. China has increasingly emphasized expanding trade with Central Asia to develop its interior and the western regions, as well as catering to domestic demand rather than solely relying on export­-led growth that has primarily benefited its coastal cities.
Q. The peace process in Afghanistan is at a nascent stage now. Could actions by China give it momentum?
A. The main obstacles to a peace process have been the Afghan Taliban’s refusal to negotiate with the Afghan government and Pakistan’s willingness to allow the Afghan Taliban open­-ended access to a sanctuary where they can organize and raise funds. The imminent departure of U.S. troops, the transfer of Taliban leaders out of Guantánamo and the transfer of responsibility for all detainees in Afghanistan to the Afghan government are removing the major reasons the Taliban have given for their refusal to meet the government. The Taliban’s open­-ended sanctuary in Pakistan greatly reduced the incentive for the Taliban to talk to the Afghan government. Pakistan wanted to retain the Afghan Taliban as an instrument of pressure against Afghanistan and the United States, given the Afghan state’s many claims against Pakistan and the warming of Afghan­-Indian and U.S.­-Indian relations.
China’s willingness to cooperate with the governments of both Pakistan and Afghanistan may enable it to reduce significantly the degree of threat that the Pakistani elite sees from Afghanistan and the U.S. Pakistan will be much more willing to provide access to the exiled Taliban leadership on its territory to China than to Afghanistan or the U.S. Since China is a neighbor with permanent reliable interests, its influence is likely to be more enduring than that of the U.S.
Q. What can you tell us about the recent meetings that China has had with officials of the Afghan Taliban? Is China now using channels to communicate with the Taliban that bypass Pakistani agencies?
A. I have no direct knowledge of these meetings. The Taliban leadership lives in Pakistan, mainly around the cities of Quetta, Karachi and Peshawar, but they managed to establish a political office in Qatar outside of direct Pakistani control. The office has no official status, and Pakistan tries to influence and pressure it, but it has a greater margin of maneuver than the leaders in Pakistan. The Taliban have denied that they have had talks with the Afghan government in China or that China is playing any mediating role. They portray their visits to Beijing as part of their longstanding relations with several countries to explain their positions.
It is possible that China, like a number of other countries, including the U.S. in 2011-12, has had direct contact with the Taliban representatives in Qatar, but this is a less salient question than in the past. President [Hamid] Karzai saw reconciliation with the Taliban as a way to undermine Pakistan’s leverage in Afghanistan, and therefore he tried to establish secret direct contacts with them independent of Pakistan. President Ghani seems to have concluded that cooperation with Pakistan is the only way to bring peace to Afghanistan, which is a politically risky position for him to take in Afghanistan, where resentment of Pakistan runs high. But that means he has no reason to bypass Pakistan in making these preliminary contacts and in asking for an end to the sanctuary. Of course, if an actual process of negotiation starts, discussion of future political arrangements will involve only Afghans. But the implementation of any such agreement, particularly of the de­mobilization and de­militarization of the Taliban, would require cooperation.
Q. What do we know about the presence of militant Uighurs in Afghanistan and the extent to which they are training in Pakistan’s tribal belt? How often do you hear Chinese officials mention concerns over security in Xinjiang?
A.
There seems to be broad agreement that there are several hundred Uighurs from the Xinjiang autonomous region engaged in militant activity or training, mainly in Pakistan, but some also in northern Afghanistan, where they may be co­-located with the Islamic Movement of Uzbekistan. Chinese officials regularly cite this as a major source of their concern over regional stability. It is difficult to evaluate the reports because Uighurs and Uzbeks are very similar linguistically and culturally, so people reported to be Uighurs may actually be Uzbeks and vice versa. My contacts in China tell me that there is little or no evidence of direct operational involvement in terrorist acts in China by Uighurs in Afghanistan and Pakistan. The Chinese seem more concerned about on­line radicalization emanating from the very substantial and nationalist Uighur community in Turkey. Another major concern is the number of Chinese citizens, not all of them Uighurs, fighting with Sunni militant groups in Syria. Some estimates place the number at around 500, but I can’t verify that.
Chinese officials also have a talking point that the U.S. has a double standard on terrorism because non­violent Uighur nationalist or separatist organizations enjoy freedom of expression in the U.S. The Chinese want to create an international consensus against the “Three Evils” of terrorism, separatism and extremism. The U.S. and European countries explain that non­violent expression of separatist or even extremist ideas is legally protected in our system.
The main origins of the conflict dynamic in Xinjiang and related terrorist attacks in China are domestic (some Chinese scholars will say this openly), but foreign­-based training or radicalization could make any conflict more violent and difficult to resolve. My impression is that the push from the government to develop interior and western China, leading to labor migration of ethnic Han and the Sinicization of local cities and towns, is the main reason that clashes have increased. It is a challenge for any large and diverse state intent on rapid development to implement it in such a way that it does not give rise to resistance by groups who feel marginalized.

Afghan President Salutes Pakistan Peace Efforts

Afghan President Ashraf Ghani on Friday saluted neighbouring Pakistan's cooperation as Kabul seeks to lay the groundwork for peace with Taliban insurgents, the latest sign of improving ties between the two nations.

Afghanistan "appreciates Pakistan's recent efforts in paving the ground for peace and reconciliation", Ghani said in a statement. "We welcome the recent position Pakistan has taken in pronouncing Afghanistan's enemy as Pakistan's."

He cited two major recent attacks as helping to bring the countries closer together -- one in Yahya Khel in Afghanistan in November that left nearly 50 people dead, and a Taliban massacre at a school in the Pakistan city of Peshawar in December that killed 153, mostly children.
Ghani's statement came after a top Pakistani minister said on Thursday that relations between the two countries had never been better.
"I think Afghanistan and Pakistan, working in close hands and in close cooperation, it will do wonders for the cooperation in the field of counter-terrorism," Pakistani Interior Minister Nisar Ali Khan said as he met with top US diplomat John Kerry in Washington.

"Relations between Afghanistan and Pakistan have never been better, and that is a very, very positive development."

Ghani also spoke after Taliban commanders said the militants would soon restart contacts with US officials in Qatar to try to get peace talks on track after more than 13 years of war in Afghanistan.

The US and the Taliban central spokesman later denied the claims, however.

There have been several attempts at starting dialogue in recent years between the Taliban, Kabul and the United States -- the Afghan government's chief supporter -- but with little success.

Last year's election of Ghani, who pledged to make peace talks a priority, as well as supportive signals from Pakistan, which has long held significant influence with the Taliban, has however boosted hopes for possible dialogue.

"Ghani has done good work to promote a dialogue for peace," one Taliban commander said. Another said his recent talks with tribal chiefs had led to progress.

Ghani however said in his statement that "there are obviously elements opposing the peace process by spreading false information to cause public confusion and anxiety".

Video Report - Ashton Carter, Defense Secretary, in Afghanistan - US May Slow Its Afghanistan Exit

Video Report - First stop, Afghanistan, for new US Defence Secretary Ash Carter

Music Video - Sam Smith - Lay Me Down

Video Report - Greece, EU agree bailout extension

Video Report - Kerry outlines U.S. and UK strategies to tackle militants

Video Report - Thousands attend anti-Maidan march in Moscow

Video Report - Ukraine conflict to dominate talks as Kerry lands in London

Music Video - 50 Cent - Like A G6 (Remix) [Best Beauties]

U.S - Giuliani’s Comments Part of a Complicated History on Race








By Jennifer Steinhauer

Mayor Rudolph W. Giuliani of New York and former Mayor David N. Dinkins at a discussion on South Africa in January 1994, the month Mr. Giuliani succeeded Mr. Dinkins.Credit Ruby Washington/The New York Times
For those who first dialed into Rudolph W. Giuliani during his “America’s mayor” phase, right after the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks — when he wowed the world with his civic leadership, soaring oratory and unifying largess — the former New York mayor’s racially charged comments about President Obama might seem puzzling.
But Mr. Giuliani’s road to and through City Hall was punctuated with racial controversy.
From his 1993 campaign challenging David N. Dinkins, the city’s first African-American mayor, during which Mr. Giuliani stood with rowdy protesting police officers — some of whom carried signs suggesting that voters should “Dump the washroom attendant!” because Mr. Dinkins had proposed a commission to look into police misconduct — to his writing off a black New Yorker killed by the police as “no altar boy” (though he actually was), Mr. Giuliani has had a complicated relationship with African-Americans.
Of course, Mr. Giuliani’s brusqueness was in no way limited to black New Yorkers. He targeted and disparaged, in no particular order, street vendors, ferret owners, artists who made paintings that offended him, Democrats at every level of government and pretty much anyone who made even minor policy critiques.
“He preferred to use a cannon on a mosquito,” said Bill Cunningham, who ran the first mayoral campaign of Michael R. Bloomberg, who succeeded Mr. Giuliani. “It was not enough to disparage a position or statement. There was some innate need to personalize attacks in order to curry favor with a target group.”
In many ways, Mr. Giuliani’s political career was formed in a tinder box of race. His first campaign against Mr. Dinkins in 1989 was defined by the sense of history many black New Yorkers sought to fulfill by electing Mr. Dinkins, but also by a decade of racial tension in New York. Roger Ailes, the president of Fox News who was Mr. Giuliani’s main media adviser in that first campaign, suggested that if his client didn’t win the second time around, “this city is going to turn into Detroit.”
Mr. Giuliani felt burned and hurt by his lack of support among minority voters in his first run for mayor, and worked hard to improve relations with black New Yorkers for his second run. By 1993, the city was besieged by racial tensions between Korean immigrants and blacks, and blacks and Jews, and there was an increasing perception that Mr. Dinkins had lost control. Mr. Giuliani narrowly beat Mr. Dinkins, though he did not make significant gains in support among black voters.
Mr. Giuliani was lauded most in his two terms in office for the reduction in crime, but the improvement was tempered by poor relations between the city’s Police Department and minorities. Most notable was the 2000 killing of the unarmed black man, Patrick Dorismond, outside a city bar, after which Mr. Giuliani made the unusual step of releasing Mr. Dorismond’s sealed juvenile police record and saying that Mr. Dorismond was “no altar boy.” (Mr. Dorismond had been an altar boy, in fact, and had even attended the same Catholic school as the mayor.)
After his failed run at the White House in 2008, Mr. Giuliani stayed largely out of the cauldron of racial discord, as the city became increasingly diverse and far less segregated by neighborhood. But he did wade back into the issue when two police officers were killed in New York late last year after a spate of protests over the police shootings of unarmed blacks across the country. Mr. Giuliani said that most blacks died at the hands of other blacks, noting, “The people who do the most for the black community in America are the police.”

His comments about Mr. Obama this week at a fund-raising event for Gov. Scott Walker of Wisconsin could be a matter of Mr. Giuliani seeking to energize conservatives preparing for a Republican primary contest, in which disparaging Mr. Obama is expected. Or it could be Mr. Giuliani speaking from the heart. Either way, his comments were not new.

U.S. - Giuliani Just Can’t Keep his Mouth Shut





By James Turnage

Ladies and Gentlemen, let me introduce you to a man who needs no introduction. He has been called many things, the latest of which is the male Sarah Palin. He has never earned any credibility as a politician, but he loves to be in the media. Ladies and Gentlemen, I give you the former Mayor of New York City, Rudy Giuliani, and I promise that he will be entertaining.’
I don’t agree with White House Spokesperson John Earnest all of the time, but I do in regards to Giuliani’s ridiculous statement Wednesday when he said that President Obama doesn’t love this country. I, too, feel sorry for Giuliani’s lack of intellect and any ability to support his outlandish statement.
On Thursday, although he faced ridicule from both sides of the aisle within the last 24 hours, he just couldn’t keep his mouth shut, just like the former half-governor of Alaska. He said he wasn’t sorry for the comment, and continues to support everything he said. Then he added that the reason the President doesn’t love the United States the way he does is because of the manner in which he was raised. Sadly, he is right. Mr. Obama was taught to question everything so that his decisions in life would be based on intellect rather than emotion and blind patriotism.
I do agree that the President doesn’t love his country the way some other political leaders did in the past. He hasn’t sent our military into unwinnable battles just to have thousands of them return in body bags; yet. He hasn’t chosen to allow his friends in the banking industry to rob America blind. He has helped millions of Americans acquire health insurance who may have suffered bankruptcy previously from catastrophic medical bills.
He says that Mr. Obama was not raised to recognize the ‘exceptionalism’ of America. Giuliani needs to watch the first episode of ‘The Newsroom.’ Jeff Daniels portrays a television journalist who is involved in a Q and A at a university. A young coed asks the panel why America is the ‘greatest country in the world.’ When Daniels, whose character is a self-proclaimed Republican, has his opportunity to speak he says ‘it’s not.’ He begins reciting a list of how far behind our nation is from other developed countries in education, caring for our poor, health insurance costs, standard of living, etc. etc. etc. The truth hurts.
To love one’s country means to love its people. The area within geographical boundaries, the monuments, and even the flag are not America. The people are what defines a nation, and his actions speak louder than Giuliani’s words; he cares about the majority of Americans, not Giuliani’s one-percent.
I have no party affiliation, and I never will. I don’t believe in political parties. This allows me to lambaste any politician who is deserving of my mockery and wrath. And when I go to the voting booth, I vote for the man or woman who I believe is the most qualified candidate. I don’t feel obliged to vote for an ‘R’ or a ‘D,’ or even and ‘I.’
When I read about Giuliani acting in ‘Palinesque’ fashion, I felt obligated to chastise him for his unqualified and misinformed statements. I’m not sure who will receive my derogatory comments tomorrow. We’ll just have to wait and see.

Al Sharpton rips Giuliani over Obama comments, says 'Rudy needs a hug'

http://www.nydailynews.com/
BY CHAUNCEY ALCORN , LARRY MCSHANE The Rev. Al Sharpton delivered a surprise response Saturday to Rudy Giuliani’s attacks on President Obama: Keep ‘em coming.
“The best thing that can happen to the Democrat that succeeds President Obama is for Rudy Giuliani to keep running his mouth,” Sharpton said at his Harlem headquarters.
“Give him all the air time you can give him, because he doesn’t know but one song to sing. He don’t realize it’s 2015. He thinks it’s ‘93.”
Sharpton did rip Giuliani as “a fading Republican who will say and do anything for attention” before offering a cure for the ex-mayor’s vitriol.
“First of all,” Sharpton said, “Rudy needs a hug.”
Giuliani, after declaring that Obama did not “love America,” doubled down on his comments by telling the Daily News that the president was influenced by communism since childhood.
“The ideas that are troubling me and are leading to this come from Communists with whom he associated since he was 9 years old,” said Giuliani, who mounted an unsuccessful 2008 GOP presidential run.
Sharpton, a Giuliani nemesis during his two terms as mayor, charged the Republican politician with playing the race card.
“He has built a lot of his career on playing with race codes,” said Sharpton. “That is what he did to David Dinkins. That is what he did to activists when he was mad.”
Giuliani — who lost to Dinkins in the 1989 mayoral race — triumphed over the incumbent four years later. Giuliani attended an NYPD police union rally at City Hall that turned ugly, with Dinkins recalling that cops were using racial epithets toward him.
“Rudy Giuliani was out there all but inciting the police to riot,” Dinkins wrote in his memoir.

President Obama's Weekly Address: We Should Make Sure the Future Is Written by Us

#PeshawarSchoolAttack - Song - Peshawar Bleeding

#PeshawarAttack - APS student succumbs to injuries






A student of Army Public School Peshawar succumbed to his injuries of December 16′s Taliban attack on Saturday.
Ishaq Amin, a tenth-grade student, was battling for his life at the city’s Combined Military Hospital (CMH) for two months since the brazen attack. He was a resident on Nothia, Peshawar.
The December 16 attack killed more than 150 people, mostly schoolchildren. Many of the survivors were critically disabled while a large number of them are prone to psychological distress, according to doctors.

Pakistan terror wave sparks rare criticism of Saudi Arabia





Pakistan and Saudi Arabia have long enjoyed close relations, but Islamabad’s new-found resolve for fighting the root causes of extremism has seen the Gulf state come in for rare criticism.
The two countries, both with majority Sunni Muslim populations, are bound together by shared Islamic religious ties, financial aid from oil-rich Saudi and Pakistan military assistance to the kingdom.
But a Taliban massacre at a school that killed more than 150 people in December, mostly children, has led the government to crack down on militants and talk of bringing religious seminaries under tighter control.
Now the country’s media and even government ministers have begun to question whether support from Saudi Arabia for seminaries, known as madrassas, is fuelling violent extremism – bringing tension to the relationship for the first time.
Last week the Saudi embassy issued a statement saying that all its donations to seminaries had government clearance, after a minister accused the Riyadh government of creating instability across the Muslim world.
The Pakistani foreign ministry responded by saying that funding by private individuals through “informal channels” would also be scrutinised closely to try to choke off funding for terror groups.
While the statement avoided mentioning Saudi Arabia specifically, it was widely interpreted as a rebuke.
Away from the seminaries, there has also been widespread criticism of the decision to allow Saudi royals to hunt the rare houbara bustard, prized in the Middle East for its supposed aphrodisiac properties, in the southern provinces of Sindh and Baluchistan.
Officials granted permission to hunt the bird, which is on the International Union for Conservation of Nature’s “red list” of threatened species, in defiance of a court order, prompting allegations that the government prized its lucrative ties to Riyadh over its own wildlife.
Badar Alam, editor of Herald magazine, said the recent wave of criticism was unprecedented.
“Saudi has vast commercial and economic interests in Pakistan. There are open questions being asked on this relationship,” he said.
“Before, nobody would ask any questions in any manner. Now even the Urdu press is asking questions.”
Donors in Saudi Arabia have long been accused of quietly funding terror groups sympathetic to the kingdom’s hardline version of Sunni Islam.
Leaked diplomatic cables by then-US secretary of State Hillary Clinton in 2009 said Saudi Arabian donors were “the most significant source of funding to Sunni terrorist groups worldwide”.
The cable cited the Taliban, Al-Qaeda and Pakistan’s Sunni Muslim sectarian militants Lashkar-e-Jhangvi as examples of where funds were being channelled.
Linked to the funding is Saudi Arabia’s long geostrategic struggle with Iran, the key Shia Muslim power in the region.
Nawaz Sharif, Pakistan’s current prime minister, enjoys particularly close ties with the Saudi royal family, which hosted him during his almost decade-long exile from Pakistan following his ouster by then military ruler Pevez Musharraf.
And last year the government said it had received a $1.5 billion “gift” from a friendly Muslim nation, widely thought by experts to be in fact a loan from Saudi Arabia.
But Najmuddin Sheikh, a former foreign secretary and ambassador, said the December attack on an army school in Peshawar, which left 153 people dead including 134 children, had opened the door for criticism.
“This has been triggered by Peshawar and a strong feeling that much of the terrorism that is here is being financed by outside countries,” he said.
“Countries like Kuwait, UAE and Qatar must also do much more at home to curtail this.”
But, he added, any efforts to cut back on foreign funding for extremist seminaries must go hand in hand with similar efforts at home.
He said this would include the state dropping its links with proxy groups that have historically been used by the military establishment to further strategic goals in Afghanistan and Indian-administered Kashmir.
“Our fund collection within Pakistan remains unimpeded. If you want more from abroad you need to do more at home,” he said.
A senior government official, speaking on condition of anonymity, agreed.
“We didn’t need the Saudis to radicalise us, we have geared ourselves to that,” he said.
And while the current mood may be critical of Riyadh, the official said in the long run the relationship was too important and too beneficial to jeopardise.
“There is no change in policy. Both the Sharif government and the military are very much on board with Saudis. Actual policy is not likely to change,” he said.

Editorial - Pakistan - Seven Miners Die




Unfortunately, familiar scenes of poverty-stricken miners, blackened faces and bleeding hands, working in extremely challenging conditions without any safety equipment, do not just exist in movies or the past. It is still happening in several parts of the world including Balochistan. On Friday, seven miners died of gas suffocation after being trapped in a coal mine in the Dukki area of the province. Reportedly, colleagues rescued over a dozen miners but seven remained trapped for over 24 hours. The rescue team, which was dispatched from Quetta, arrived too late and by then, the miners, who could have been saved if helped had arrived in time, had lost their lives. As per reports, such incidents are not uncommon in the province, especially in Dukki, where the majority of workers are Afghan nationals.
Coal extracted by these poorly equipped miners from resource-rich areas such as Dukki is used in industries in Punjab and elsewhere. Is it not true that these dangerous jobs are reserved for those who have no other alternatives for employment? Is it also not true that they are paid poorly, provided no compulsory safety equipment and that basic health units are either poorly equipped or do not exist at all in close proximity to mining sites? While we aspire to bring awareness to world on the issue of reckless over-exploitation of natural resources, it would appear that we are failing to appeal to the conscience of those who exploit human beings for business. What good are flourishing industries and running engines if the cost is dead miners? The problem will persist as long as economic activity and reward continues to overshadow human suffering. Protection of labour isn’t about economy. It is a moral issue. An inevitable consequence of better labour laws and safety equipment is higher cost for business and less loss of life, which is of course good for labour and bad for profits. If economic considerations are allowed to dictate laws and safety precautions related to labour force, the latter will always lose and lose big.
In Pakistan, use of labour is synonymous with exploitation of labour. People are desperate. They need work even if it threatens to kill them. The government has done nothing to alleviate their condition and implement standards deemed fit by the International Labour Organisation (ILO). Will anyone be held accountable for the incident in Dukki? Who is guilty of failing to provide safety equipment to the deceased miners? Who is responsible for the poor health facilities? Why did it take 24 hours for rescue teams to reach Dukki from Quetta? Why were none available closer to the area? The government must ensure that such blatant exploitation is halted. To understand the situation better, ministers may find it helpful to work alongside the miners in Dukki for a day.

http://nation.com.pk/editorials/21-Feb-2015/seven-miners-die

Pakistan - We are confused but terrorists are not!











Those who are arrested under allegations of blasphemy cannot find a lawyer to defend them in a court of law but, on the other hand, recently a procession led by a team of 90 lawyers volunteered to defend a convicted murderer, Mumtaz Qadri


The terrorists are back in business in dead earnest. From Shikarpur to Peshawar and then to Islamabad they have come hard on the state, which is confused and directionless. The ‘look busy, do nothing’ official fanfare may delude many naïve followers of national media but such spineless rhetoric fails to impress a determined foe. While Operation Zarb-e-Azb is being projected as a grand success, we find that the terrorists are still on the loose all over the country. We are still struggling to find clarity of purpose and sincerity of intent in the overall aim and objectives of the counterterrorism plan. The very nomenclature itself diminishes the plan’s strategic importance as counterterrorism is an operational level activity.

I have, time and again, emphasised the need for a comprehensive anti-extremism plan where counterterrorism can become its operational level plan. We must know that the crop of extremism is cultivated and fertilised over a long period of time before farmers are able to take the harvest of terrorism to the market. The role of the anti-terrorism plan is to stop the harvest finding its way to the market. However, a more comprehensive anti-extremism strategic plan would focus more on stopping the cultivation of the crop that yields terrorism.

Extremism manifests itself in many ways. Our emotional attachment with the issue of blasphemy is a very potent form of extremism in Pakistani society. The essence of blasphemy is in the fact that opinions are silenced by threats of violence. In Pakistan we can identify three forms of blasphemy that are often associated with actual physical violence. First, the most commonly known is religious blasphemy where anyone can be accused of disrespecting a holy personality of the Muslims. Second is if the military establishment feels offended by any statement or accusation. Third is if family honour, often closely linked with females, is thought to be attacked.

Blasphemy laws, introduced by an army dictator decades ago, and which discriminate between holy personalities of different faith communities in the country, and hence are ultra vires of the fundamental rights guaranteed by the Constitution, are still a no-go area for the so-called sovereign parliament of the country. Those who are arrested under allegations of blasphemy cannot find a lawyer to defend them in a court of law but, on the other hand, recently a procession led by a team of 90 lawyers, which included former judges of superior courts, volunteered to defend a convicted murderer, Mumtaz Qadri. Interestingly, the Islamabad High Court (IHC) heard the appeal case after a delay of three years as no judge was reportedly interested in hearing the case.

When it comes to blasphemy against holy personalities in the military, the situation is not much different. Saleem Shahzad had to lose his life for disclosing that cells within the navy had facilitated the Mehran Base attack. Hamid Mir nearly lost his life and is now tight-lipped for committing the same offence. No wonder no one has dared to ask the question: what accountability has taken place of those uniformed officers who failed in their duty of providing security to a commercially run school in Peshawar even though the attack on the school had been officially made imminent? The king can do no wrong is the basis of the sovereign’s immunity in English law. In Pakistan, its equivalent maxim is the general can do no wrong.

I have argued many times that development means expansion of freedoms and enjoyment of fundamental human rights, and should not be seen merely as launching mega projects. We expected that the new government would also give attention to the dilapidated intellectual infrastructure in the country. However, after about two years in power, we have not seen the senseless ban on YouTube lifted. Is it not ironic to the point of comedy that YouTube is free in Mecca and Medina but banned in Islamabad and Karachi? By retaining such regressive bans on the one hand and declaring a war on jihadi outfits on the other, the government is sending confused signals. The hate preacher in the terrorism-infested Lal Masjid of Islamabad is still a state paid official. Such indicators do not reflect well upon the seriousness of the government in pursuing a well-intentioned strategic plan with a clear vision. Critics are not entirely wrong in asserting that there is a complete lack of coherence in the strategic thinking of policy makers at the highest level.

Anti-terrorism seems to be hopelessly confused with anti-extremism. The former amounts to curing symptoms and not addressing the causes as terrorism is the outcome of the choices we made in the past in various fields of public policy. In one of my previous writings I have argued that faith is used by different sections of society differently depending on their particular social needs. While the haves enjoy religion for contentment and rituals purposes, the have-nots use communal faith for organising and motivational purposes. If the ruling classes are using religion to maximise their social control, it is very naïve to expect that the deprived classes will not use it for their own empowerment by raising motivational slogans of jihad and sharia. Using a comprehensive anti-extremism strategy the state has to take full control of religion and root out all symbols of extremism and intolerance from law, syllabi and other strata of society if we are keen about restoring peace and harmony.

Pakistan - Former President Zardari grieved over mine tragedy in Loralai in Balochistan

mediacellppp.wordpress.com



Former President Asif Ali Zardari has expressed profound grief and shock over the death of seven miners from Khyber Pakhtunkhwa due to suffocation after being trapped in a coalmine in Dukki area in Loralai, Balochistan. 
Seven miners died on Friday after they were trapped in the mine for over twenty four hours when fire broke out in the mine and the exit was blocked while neither safety equipment nor rescue teams were immediately on hand. 
In a statement today Mr. Asif Ali Zardari called for a thorough probe into the tragedy to ascertain whether safety precautions and observance of relevant laws was sacrificed for profit and greed and why the rescue teams were so late in arriving at the scene, fixing responsibility for the same and punishment to those found negligent and guilty.
“A thorough probe must be carried out in the reports that the miners remained trapped for twenty four hours before rescue teams arrived and there were no safety protocols in place for the mine workers”.Steps must also be taken to ensure that such tragedies did not occur again, he said. 
The avoidable tragedy also brings into focus the plight of the labour and working classes driven by poverty to perform dangerous jobs under deplorable conditions and calls for urgent measures for ensuring safety of the poor workers, the former President said in his statement.We owe it to the labour to take concrete steps to alleviate the condition of the wage earners and workers by implementing safety standards in mines and other dangerous occupations, he said. 
The PPP Co-Chair also called for adequate compensation to the families of the victims. Mr. Asif Ali Zardari also prayed for those who died in the mishap and patience to the bereaved families and asked Party leaders to visit the bereaved families.

Pakistani politicians remain a security handicap












By Farhan Bokhari 


It’s the government’s job to bolster the successes made by the military-led establishment against the Taliban but that unfortunately is unlikely as the Sharif administration plumbs new depths of incompetence
Pakistan’s ongoing fight against violent extremism continues to provoke a backlash in the shape of reprisal terrorist attacks by hard-core Taliban militants. And yet, the ongoing violence was easily predictable in a country where militant activity has actively grown in the past 36 years since the 1979 invasion of Afghanistan by the former Soviet Union provoked a long-term security crisis for Afghanistan and Pakistan.
In tackling the challenge, Pakistan began turning the corner in June last year when its army chose to launch a wide-ranging campaign in the North Waziristan along the Afghan border. That effort has only gained further momentum since December 16 when 150 people, mostly teenaged students, were killed in a particularly brutal Taliban attack on a school in the northern city of Peshawar.
While that attack highlighted Pakistan’s helplessness, it also created an opportunity for Pakistan’s army to step up the fight against extremism. However, evidence available just in the past week has also demonstrated the degree to which the Pakistan army successfully followed up investigating the December 16 attack. Of the estimated 27 militants involved in planning and/or execution of that attack, up to nine have been killed while another 12 have been captured, including six taken into custody in Afghanistan.
Closer coordination
In sharp contrast to the adversity of the challenge, Pakistan’s army-run security establishment led by General Raheel Sharif, the army’s chief of staff, has also firmly made inroads in beating back the Taliban advance. In spite of the growing casualty count, significant progress in the shape of improving ties with Afghan president Ashraf Gani’s administration has laid the ground for closer coordination.
During a trip to Kabul in the past week, General Sharif who now appears to be personally overseeing Pakistan’s Afghan policy, made a landmark statement when he said publicly that the enemy of Afghanistan remains the enemy of Pakistan. So profound were those words for Afghanistan that they were subsequently hailed by Afghan officials as evidence of a new era of unprecedented cooperation.
General Sharif’s visit to Kabul, which followed an earlier visit on December 17 — a day after the Peshawar school attack, reportedly also included follow up discussions to a standing request from Pakistan for Afghanistan to hand over Mullah Fazlullah, the notorious head of Pakistan’s Taliban movement. Fazlullah, according to Pakistani officials, is hiding in Afghanistan’s Kunar province over the border from Pakistan, from where he directed the attack on the Peshawar school.
Fazlullah rose to notoriety as the militant figure who led the Taliban campaign in Pakistan’s northern Swat Valley some years ago, from where he was driven out by the Pakistan army. Though Fazlullah remains on the run, its only a matter of time before he is successfully targeted either by US forces in Afghanistan or Afghan forces on Afghan soil — or on Pakistan’s territory, if he chooses to return.
Meanwhile, on Friday came reports of the resumption of peace talks between the Afghan Taliban and Gani’s government in Doha, Qatar. This brings the two sides to the negotiating table after the process was disrupted a while ago. Western officials have acknowledged the event as a result of General Sharif’s successful behind-the-scene efforts to bring the two parties back to the negotiating table.
While such diplomacy in Afghanistan gathers momentum, the biggest change to resolving Pakistan’s security crisis has indeed taken place within the country.
The speed with which Pakistan’s security and intelligence services identified suspects involved in the Peshawar attack, and subsequently moved to target most of them, marks a sea change from the times when militants would often remain out of the reach of the law.
At the same time, General Sharif’s rapidly growing popularity on Pakistan’s streets speaks volumes for the public’s acknowledgement of his effort. That said, however, the country’s ruling politicians remain many steps behind the need of the hour. In sharp contrast to the tension surrounding security conditions, ongoing stories of large amounts of money changing hands ahead of the upcoming elections for the upper house of parliament, the Senate, say much about the dismal state of Pakistan’s politics.
Out of sync with reality
Clearly, corruption is at its peak and Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif, as well as the political structure he represents, remain out of sync with the powerful reality of Pakistan’s mounting challenges. In addition to the state of the country’s politics, the economy continues to underperform in ways that remain fairly unprecedented.
An ongoing economic crisis across the country has surrounded Pakistanis as never before in ways ranging from widespread fuel shortages to an outright absence of jobs. And while Sharif’s government visibly remains one of the most incompetent administrations in the country’s history, little has been done to accept political responsibility.
To date, not a single minister has been held accountable for the underperformance of his or her area of responsibility.
In a nutshell, there is apparent hope for the immediate security crisis to begin being tackled if indeed General Sharif and his colleagues continue to make inroads in the space occupied by the Taliban. But sustaining that success remains the job of Pakistan’s ruling politicians who continue to demonstrate one set of failure after another.
Going forward, an end to the Taliban advance, hopefully marked by a reversal of its success, will mark the first step towards regaining space lost by Pakistan. But in the midst of this apparent ray of hope, there is little to suggest that Sharif and his co-politicians are able or willing to rise to the occasion.

    Malala - Sacrifices of Peshawar's martyred children won't go in vain













     Nobel laureate Malala Yousafzai on Saturday said that sacrifices of Peshawar’s school children will not go wasted, adding that steps need to be taken in order to stop incidents like Peshawar’s APS School attack.
    Addressing a ceremony by Citizens for Democracy at Arts Council in Karachi through video link, Malala said that she is proud of her Pakistani nationality and that she wants children to get higher education.
    She said she is happy that Pakistani children talking about their rights and education and that “if we can give anything to our children, it is the gift of peace”.
    Malala said she stands in solidarity with Pakistan’s brave children.

    Pakistan - Zardari assigns task to party leaders to stop 'horse trading'


    Former president Asif Ali Zardari on Saturday assigned key tasks to party leaders to stop ‘horse trading’ in the Senate elections. Zardari is reportedly contacting political parties himself for this purpose, Dunya News reported.
    According to the sources, Khursheed Shah, Rehman Malik, Farhatullah Babar and Khanzada Khan have been assigned tasks by party’s top leadership in order to prevent ‘horse trading’ in Senate elections.
    Khanzada has been tasked with talking to leaders of the political parties in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa assembly, Rehman Malik with talking to MQM and other parties and Khursheed Shah and Farhatullah Babar are establishing contacts with ANP, PML-N, Sherpao group and other political parties. They have also met ANP chief Asfandyar Wali only a day ago.