Friday, February 20, 2015

U.S. - Justice Department to seek emergency stay to allow immigration action


The U.S. Justice Department will seek an emergency stay to block a decision by a federal judge and allow eligible immigrants to apply for benefits granted under President Obama's executive action, the White House said on Friday.
Immigration advocates have called on the administration to take legal action to reverse the injunction issued by U.S. District Judge Andrew Hanen that halted the issuance of work permits to eligible immigrants one day before the program's launch.
But seeking a stay comes with added headaches for the Obama administration.
Hanen must approve the stay and the Justice Department is concerned he could drag his feet or deny it.
Delaying a decision could keep the administration from filing an appeal in the 5th Circuit, where the decision would be taken out of Hanen's hands.
Approximately 4.7 million undocumented immigrants are expected to be granted relief from deportation under the program if it is allowed to go through.
The Justice Department will file paperwork to seek a stay by Monday, White House spokesman Josh Earnest said.

Video - Obama: Republicans want to be party of the Middle Class

President Obama To Hold Immigration Town Hall Meeting In Miami





South Florida is in for a presidential visit next week. President Obama will visit Miami on Wednesday, February 25th to attend an immigration town-hall style meeting at Florida International University’s main campus.
Immigration has always been a hot topic in South Florida and continues to be even though a Texas judge temporarily blocked the president’s plan to shield more than 4 million immigrants living in the country illegally from deportation.
About a third of the immigrants now living in the United States illegally would be eligible for temporary protection if Obama’s latest orders are upheld in court, either because they were brought to the U.S. as children or because their own children have legal status in the country.
Despite the legal setbacks, President Obama plans to forge ahead by speaking directly to the immigrant community that must now endure this latest delay to protections from deportation.
The nationally televised event, hosted by Miami-based Telemundo and MSNBC anchor José Díaz-Balart, will be in English and Spanish.
Tickets designated for FIU will be made available to students.

President Obama to GOP: Stop copying me on economy



President Barack Obama sought to reclaim some ownership over an issue that is suddenly a hot topic among top Republicans, telling an audience on Friday that he welcomes his rival party focusing on income inequality, but questioned whether it was anything more than talk.
"Now that their grand predictions of doom and gloom and death panels and Armageddon haven't come true. The sky hasn't fallen, chicken little is quiet," Obama said. "The new plan is to re-brand themselves as the party of the middle class. I am not making this up."
To laughs from the Democratic National Committee audience in Washington, D.C., Obama added: "I am encouraged they are speaking about middle class and about wages. But there is this old saying, you can't just talk the talk. ... You've got to walk the walk."
Income inequality and the growing gap between the richest and poorest Americans has become a primary issue in the 2016 election and many Republicans vying for the party's nomination have focused on the issue. The comments have not gone unnoticed by Democrats and the White House.
"We're facing right now a divided America when it comes to the economy," said Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas, after Obama's January address to the nation.
"Income inequality has worsened under this administration," Sen. Rand Paul, R-Kentucky, said after the President's State of the Union speech.
    On Friday, Obama took on Paul directly, noting that the 2016 hopeful once said his party needs to show up "up on the South Side of Chicago" and shout "at the top of our lungs: 'We are the party of jobs and opportunity.'"
    "I think that is encouraging that he wants to go to the South Side of Chicago," Obama said with a smile. "I was just home on the South Side of Chicago yesterday and I guarantee you that Senator Paul would be welcome there. We are a friendly bunch."
    Obama added: "I mean, it is a little strange if people show up and just start shouting on the top of their lungs. But we are friendly, it would be OK."
    When Obama first mentioned Paul, some in the audience groaned at his name. Hearing this, Obama said, "No, Rand is an interesting guy."
    The President views the improving economy after a difficult recession as a potential cornerstone of his legacy. In the foreword to a report on the nation's brightening fiscal picture from the White House Counsel of Economic Advisors, Obama writes "the United States has just concluded a breakthrough year."
    Obama has made fewer references to the issue of income inequality in recent months in favor the term "middle class economics," which was a major theme of his State of the Union speech.
    Aides to the President insist GOP leaders have flocked to the issue of income inequality only in an attempt to diminish Democratic claims to the nation's improving economy. Before the speech, a White House official said Obama would use his DNC speech to call out Republicans for what he sees as hypocrisy.
    "So far, at least, the rhetoric has not matched the reality," Obama said on Friday. "I think the shift in rhetoric that they are engaging in is good, if it actually leads them to take different actions. If it doesn't, then it is just spin."
    The President also seemed to lightly touch on recent comments by former New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani, who said earlier this week that he doesn't think President Barack Obama "loves America."
    "This is not just a sports contest, this Is not just who's up and down at any given point, it's not about notches on a belt, it's not about ideological battles an proving how smart you are," Obama said. "It's about making this nation we love more perfect."
    Republicans, in response to most positive economic numbers, have said there are still glaring vulnerabilities in the nation's recovery.
    "After spending the last six years growing Washington instead of the middle class, it's no surprise President Obama can only point fingers rather than point to meaningful success," said Republican National Committee spokesman Michael Short. "The reality is Americans have suffered under the slowest economic recovery in modern times, and on his watch, the middle class lost its status as being the world's richest as more and more families fall out rather than move up."
    House Republicans have had a similar response to the President's message.
    "There's a reason why the Democratic Party has lost the House, the Senate, governorships, and more than 900 state legislative seats in recent years. President Obama's liberal agenda has left America's working class families behind," Boehner spokesman Cory Fritz said.

    Urdu Music Video - Khuda kare kay mohabbat mein

    Amid fighting in tribal areas, Pakistan braces for a long and deadly war





    By Tim Craig


    When 10 Pakistani soldiers tried to dislodge Taliban militants from a madrassa near the Afghan border this summer, their advance was crippled by relentless gunfire. Within minutes, two soldiers were dead, and Imran Ali had so many bullets in his legs he couldn’t tell whether they were still attached.
    For 22 agonizing hours, Ali said he curled up on the floor waiting for other soldiers to fight their way in to rescue him. After finally being airlifted to safety, his left leg was amputated at the knee, and he became another victim of the Pakistani army’s latest offensive against Islamist militants in the restive tribal area of North Waziristan.

    “I received so many bullets, I still can’t figure them all out,” Ali, 25, recalled recently at a military rehabilitation hospital in this city. “But this is for the survival of the country, and God willing, we are going to win this war.”
    Ali is among nearly 800 Pakistani soldiers who have been wounded since the military launched its North Waziristan operation in June. Two hundred nineteen have been killed, adding to a toll of about 4,400 Pakistani troops who have lost their lives battling Islamist militants in northwestern Pakistan since 2002. That’s nearly twice as many soldiers as the United States lost in the same period in neighboring Afghanistan.
    Now, just two months after the Pakistani Taliban slaughtered 150 students and teachers at an army-run school in the city of Peshawar, military leaders are assessing just how much more blood will be spilled on the battlefield.
    Despite the growing resolve of Pakistani soldiers in their fight against Islamist extremism, military leaders here remain worried about diverting too many troops away from their traditional mission of defending the eastern border with arch-foe India. But those concerns are tempered by fears that militants are evolving into smaller and more erratic groups that will be testing Pakistani forces for years — perhaps decades.
    In a recent interview, Defense Minister Khawaja Asif said he hopes the bulk of the fighting in North Waziristan will be over within “a few months.” But a senior Pakistani military official, speaking on the condition of anonymity, said current plans call for keeping up to 170,000 soldiers — almost one-third of the entire force — near the Afghan border through at least 2019.
    Such an extended presence would allow the military to safeguard recent gains in North Waziristan, which has long served as a base for al-Qaeda, while still being able to quickly respond to emerging threats, includingefforts by the Islamic State militants to gain a foothold in the region.
    “We are now basically fighting for the defense of the subcontinent,” the official said. “It’s not only for Pakistan; it’s for the entire South Asia. With the withdrawal of NATO from Afghanistan, the entire burden has fallen on Pakistan.”
    Some analysts and U.S. officials are skeptical, however, that the Pakistani army can stomach a prolonged fight against Islamist militants, some of whom were nurtured by Pakistani defense and intelligence agencies as bulwarks against India and might still be viewed as assets. Other analysts say that even if the military fights stoutly, it is unclear whether it can win.
    “This is a mission that may well be beyond their capability,” said Jonah Blank, a Pakistan expert at the Rand Corporation, a nonprofit research group based in Santa Monica, Calif. “The U.S., after 13 years in Afghanistan, has not been able to put the Taliban out of business . . . and that is the most powerful military the world has ever seen. So it may be unrealistic to expect that the Pakistani military could eliminate the Taliban or even reduce it to a bare-bones operation.”
    Asif, the defense minister, said skeptics need to give the military time, perhaps up to two years, to prove its resolve.
    “This is a menace the world has to face, and it’s not only in Pakistan,” Asif said. “The Middle East, North Africa, Europe, there are so many conflict areas and the world has to take care of it and come to grips with it.”
    Shaukat Qadir, a retired Pakistani army brigadier, said soldiers were deeply affected by the Taliban assault on the army-run school in Peshawar. After years of half-hearted efforts to combat Islamist militant groups, Pakistani soldiers and commanders finally “feel this war is worth fighting,” Qadir said.
    “You have to fight your own people, but nonetheless, they now know it needs to be done,” said Qadir, adding that troops are also energized by the humble, hands-on leadership style of Pakistan’s powerful army chief, Raheel Sharif.
    That resolve was evident at the Armed Forces Institute of Rehabilitation Medicine in Rawalpindi, a city adjacent to Islamabad, the Pakistani capital. On a recent visit to one ward, a dozen soldiers in crisp blue hospital gowns, many of them missing limbs, were sitting up in their beds.
    “I am very much hopeful that, yes, things are getting better and we will win this war,” said Muhammad Rafiq, 19, who lost a foot when he stepped on a bomb in the tribal area of South Waziristan, where troops are also deployed. “We are very much into it, and the whole nation is now into it.”
    The injured soldiers said they were surprised, however, that they are fighting an enemy far different from the one they had expected to meet when they enlisted.
    “All of the thinking of India being the enemy for this country, I felt it, too, when I joined the army,” said Talat Mehmood, 30, who lost his right leg while fighting in South Waziristan two years ago. “But this new enemy is equally dangerous, equally dreadful, and needs to be taken care of.”
    As more soldiers are injured, they often show up here at the rehabilitation hospital. Considered Pakistan’s version of the Walter Reed National Military Medical Center in Bethesda, Md., the hospital opened in 2005. It recently expanded from 100 to 150 beds to treat an influx of wounded soldiers, officials said.
    During past Pakistani military conflicts, injured soldiers were fitted with wooden artificial limbs that wobbled under use. Now, in a basement workshop at the hospital, technicians sculpt temporary plaster prosthetics by hand. The hospital also increasingly provides patients with flexible plastic and metal prosthetics common in the West.
    It is also branching out to offer speech therapy as well as occupational and traumatic brain-injury therapy.
    “We are trying to say to these soldiers who have been injured that they can remain a useful part of society,” said Col. Khalid Siddiqui, a specialist at the hospital.
    But Maj. Gen. Akhtar Waheed, the head of the hospital, said it might be decades before the army truly recovers from its battle against militants. He noted that Pakistan, a country that is intensely proud of its armed forces, provides lifetime care to wounded soldiers.
    “This population is 19, 20, 25 years old, and they have to live another 40 or 50 years,” Waheed said of his patients. “Once you have sacrificed for your country, even if it’s an injury to their finger tip, we have to take care of them.”

    Christian Tortured, Forced to Confess Murder in Pakistan Is Acquitted After Four-Year Battle




    Christian Pakistani man Imtiaz Masih has been acquitted after a four-year legal battle when he was tortured and forced to confess to the killing of his Muslim employer's brother.
    The European Center of Law and Justice announced on Thursday that its affiliate in Pakistan, the Organization for Legal Aid, managed to successfully acquit Masih after a court found that the prosecution witnesses made conflicting statements, and could not be trusted.

    "False accusations of crimes are all too common in Pakistan. Usually, people falsely accuse others to settle personal scores or simply to implicate an easy target to divert attention from the real culprit," the ECLJ explained.
    "Because Pakistani Christians are generally poor and uneducated and do not have means to fight with wealthy Muslims, they become easy targets of persecution. Widespread corruption in the criminal justice system, especially in the police department, facilitates such false accusations."
    The case stemmed from an incident on Nov. 9, 2010, when Muhammad Anwar, the brother of Muhammad Sarwar, Masih's employer, was shot and killed outside his house. Anwar's other brother, Muhammad Aslam, initially told police that Anwar had been killed by Muslim landlords over a land dispute, but later changed his statement and alleged that Masih had committed the murder.
    Aslam and Sarwar then abducted the Christian man, and tortured him until he was forced to confess to the crime to the police.
    OLA has been helping Masih throughout the trial, and in March 2011 managed to get him successfully released on bail.
    The minority Christian community in Pakistan has often faced cases of blasphemy, which persecution watchdog groups say is a way to suppress religious freedom.
    The American Center for Law and Justice, which also shared the news of the acquittal on its website, has been advocating for a number of Christians imprisoned for their faith in Muslim-dominated countries.
    The group started petitions and led campaigns that helped free Christian mother Mariam Ibrahim, who was imprisoned in Sudan and sentenced to death for refusing to identify as a Muslim.
    The ACLJ has also been urging the Obama administration to do all that it can to secure the release of American citizen and pastor Saeed Abedini, who's been imprisoned in Iran since September 2012, also for hisChristian faith.

    Pakistan - The new action plan: war by committee

    By Ayaz Amir


    Loadshedding we tackled with rhetoric. Terrorism is being tackled by something better: rhetoric and committee meetings. Not a day goes by without another meeting, apex this and apex that, army chief and ISI chief dutifully attending…and looking glum for the most part. Full marks to their stamina…at this rate they’ll have little time for anything else.

    Provincial apex committees are good for hot air and good intentions. Implementation rests with the chief ministers. Stand them in a row and look at them. How much confidence do these knights inspire?

    Much of the spirit of Peshawar has already evaporated as more terrorist attacks continue and the government responds with more committee meetings and more brave declarations about rooting out terrorism. The Allied and Axis powers combined would not have held so many committee meetings during the entire length of the Second World War as have been held here in the last few months.

    Three Shia imambargahs have been attacked in quick succession: Shikarpur, Peshawar and now Islamabad. Is more proof needed of Shia vulnerability, of their status as a special target for our terrorists? Yet, is there any special plan for the protection of imambargahs? After the attack on the imambargah in Islamabad the Rawalpindi and Islamabad police forces were arguing about jurisdiction. This is the state of our preparation. And army commandos rushed to the scene of action. If the army must do everything of what use is the police?

    These are the same police forces which ran before activists of Tahirul Qadri’s Pakistan Awami Tehreek. The same Islamabad police which became a laughingstock when a lone gunman stood for hours in the Blue Area, two guns in his hands and his wife and two children with him, and for hours on end the Islamabad police couldn’t figure out what to do. 

    There’s nothing intrinsically wrong with the Punjab or Islamabad police. The same human material goes into the police and the army. But the army is trained on professional lines. Its ethos is different and no one can interfere in the chain of command. Divisional and corps commanders do not interfere in regimental appointments. That is the prerogative of the regimental commander.

    But the police we deal with differently…favourites picked for choice postings, Station House Officers recommended by politicians or other ‘influentials’, chief ministers (this is especially true of Punjab) interviewing and selecting District Police Officers. When the office of inspector general is treated as a post office, the IG not master in his own house, how on earth do we expect the police to perform as well as the army? Speeches and committee meetings won’t solve this problem. 

    The army chief declares in Karachi that appointments in the Karachi and Sindh police should be on merit and not on the basis of sifarish or personal likes and dislikes. In KP the IG (reportedly) is allowed a free hand. But since the army is now taking the major decisions – ‘soft coup’ and all that – and Gen Raheel is very much the power behind the civilian throne, shouldn’t the army command ensure that the principle of no political interference in the police be applied across the board? Army and ISI are just one front in this war. Anti-terrorist efforts will fall short unless all the police forces, down to the district and thana levels, are fully engaged in this fight. 

    Isn’t it high time also that the police were freed from unwanted protocol and VIP duty? The situation today is that while terrorists can strike at will and people at large are defenceless the so-called VIP class suffers from over-protection. Which US president or British prime minister has a thousand policemen posted outside his private residence? Sons and daughters go around with long escorts. Second and third begums enjoy official security. Remove official security from private residences and I bet rulers will become more alive to the terrorist threat. 

    What else should be done? Two models before us can serve as examples: (1) how the police chief in Indian Punjab, KPS Gill, was instrumental in crushing Sikh militancy after the storming of the Golden Temple in Amritsar; and (2) the way Naseerullah Babar, then interior minister, spearheaded the operation against militancy and terrorism in Karachi in 1995.

    Without going into other details, suffice it to say that Gill was given complete authority. A Sikh himself, he dealt with the Sikh insurrection with a ruthless and merciless hand. Every method, including encounter killings, was permissible. Thus it was that the problem was licked.

    Naseerullah Babar, overseeing the operation himself, gave the Karachi police a free hand. Intelligence support came from the Intelligence Bureau, not ISI and MI. Thus it was a civilian show from first to last but to date the only operation in Karachi which succeeded, breaking the back of terrorism and bringing a semblance of peace to the city…a process completely reversed when Benazir Bhutto’s government was dismissed (and after the elections Nawaz Sharif became prime minister).

    When the tide turned police officers who had distinguished themselves in the Babar operation were picked up by the very militant outfits they had fought…and tortured and killed. In other words, the state was unable to protect its own. When this happens how do you fight anything?

    So today Pakistan’s problem is to find for each province one KPS Gill or one Naseerullah Babar. The present lot won’t do, having given enough evidence of their lack of capacity and ability. They may be good for other things but defeating terrorism is just not their cup of tea. This doesn’t mean we have a national government or an army takeover…only this that operational command should be in the hands not of photo op specialists and speech-makers but men of decision and action. 

    In other words, for the police freedom from Raiwind and freedom from Bilawal House. Balochistan calls for something else. There we have too much of military interference. The chief minister should not have the army or its agencies breathing down his neck all the time. 

    Is the CIA or MI6 involved in any real-estate business? Here the IB is up to its neck in a huge housing scheme in Islamabad and there is no one to put an end to this nonsense. Even the army has to make up its mind: what comes first, the irresistible charms of real estate or the demands of the war against terrorism. As if the full-page ads selling the dreams of villas in Dubai weren’t enough, there is DHA Karachi doing equally well, selling the charms of various projects. If a tenth of our zest for real estate were ploughed into our war against terrorism we would probably get to see better results. 

    This is going to be a long struggle and more blood will be spilt before it is over. The lessons, however, should be clear: half-measures will not do; layers of security for the ruling class will not do; and the benefits of empty gestures are limited. Of initiative and audacity we certainly need more but it is not going to come from heroes of the spoken word, guftar ke ghazi, who quickly become back-seaters when it comes to actually doing something. 




    Pakistan - Settling the situation in Balochistan

    According to press reports, 'unknown men' blew up two towers of high transmission lines in Balochistan's Nasirababd area on Sunday, disrupting power supply to 20 districts of the province, including Quetta. In a similar incident two days earlier, a transmission line was bombed in another part of the Nasirabad district. On Saturday, Chief Justice of Balochistan High Court Justice Mohammad Maskanzai narrowly escaped remote-controlled bomb blast while passing through Noshki. So far, no one has claimed responsibility for these incidents. The province is infested with different kinds of militants including the Taliban, sectarian extremists and Baloch insurgents; any one of them could be the culprit. However, blowing up gas and power transmission lines has long been the hallmark of the insurgents, and hence they are the key suspects in the present incident. 

    When Dr Abdul Malik Baloch took over the chief minister's office vowing to bring back 'angry' Baloch youth into the mainstream, hopes arose of reconciliation since he enjoys a lot of respect among the nationalists. A while ago, he had made a special trip to Britain, where some of the insurgency leaders have been given asylum. But nothing came out of the meeting because he does not seem to have the requisite authority to address their demands. Meanwhile, 'enforced disappearances' and body dumping - the main source of Baloch anger all across the political spectrum - continued despite the apex court's intervention. During his recent visit to London, the Army chief is said to have asked the government there to repatriate the rebel leaders, so far without success. 

    Islamabad and Rawalpindi have been complaining of outsiders fuelling the insurgency - triggered by the Musharraf government's military operation that resulted in the murder of Baloch nationalist leader, Nawab Akbar Bugti. It is hardly surprising if interested outsiders come to fish in troubled waters. With increasing Chinese involvement in the development of the deep-sea Gwadar Port as well as commerce and transport corridors traversing Balochistan, they are to become more curious and concerned about what goes on in the province. The powers-that-be therefore would be wise to do whatever it takes to settle the situation. Understandably, it is not easy to talk to violent extremists who have been challenging the state and killing FC and security forces personnel, believed to be acting at the behest of the country's enemies. But fighting alone will not help. It is a complex problem and calls for a change of strategy. The Prime Minister, during a recent briefing at the Southern Command Headquarters in Quetta - attended among others, by CoAS and senior members of the federal and provincial governments - directed both political and military leaderships to devise a joint strategy to ensure peace in the province. Talking and fighting at the same time would be the best way forward. The civilian leadership of the province should be duly empowered to talk to the insurgents while the military keeps its pressure on. 

    Pakistan - ''Model Town Inquiry''






    If ever the government needed any validation on the infinitesimal attention span of the populace, it sits before them in the form of the Model Town incident of June 17th, 2014.
    It has now been eight months since 14 members of the public were shot to their deaths on the streets of an upscale neighbourhood in the heart of Lahore, and over 100 people injured by bullets and police beatings.
    The entire episode was being broadcast live on the nation’s televisions, as the Punjab police under the leadership of the provincial and federal PML-N government massacred unarmed activists.
    In the aftermath of the tragedy, provincial Law Minister Rana Sanaullah was asked to step down in a terribly concealed facade of accountability, where he was praised publicly for his services to the homeland, most significantly claiming the role of Chief Scapegoat for the entire affair.
    The PML-N government survived the Model Town massacre, and it survives it every single day since June 17th.

    The frequently tragic social and security landscape has done a great service to the grit and resilience of the sitting government.
    There is a continuous onslaught of distractions demanding and diverting the attention of the populace at all times, and so holding them to task for any single tragedy becomes impossible.
    Yet, there are few cases of state violence in our recent history as brazen as the Model Town incident.
    Though the state frequently throws its weight around in the information black hole that is Balochistan, against minorities and the helpless every single day, this was urban Lahore and as close to “home” for the PML-N as it could get.
    Yet, where is the first slither of accountability? Where is the citizenry, the civil society demanding that justice be delivered? On Wednesday, the Lahore High Court expressed serious concerns that the Punjab government was actively protecting the culprits and sitting on the judicial inquiry report.
    The report is still not being made public, because the government needs time to prepare a fitting reply.

    For eight months, the government has not had the time to draft a reply to the massacre of its citizens by its own police force in the heart of its roost.
    For eight months the murderers and officials in charge have been living the lives of free men protected by the PML-N.
    On what basis can the government withhold the findings of an independent judicial commission? Is that not the whole purpose of an independent inquiry into the matter? The Model Town killings could well be the undoing of this government; those seeking justice must realise the gravity of the inquiry’s findings and ensure that it is made public as early as possible.

    Bonded labour in Pakistan: a humanitarian crisis












    The phenomenon of bonded labour is very common in the brick kiln sector, in all the provinces of Pakistan, with a majority of brick kilns located in Punjab
    The word slavery evokes images from history from when slaves were driven by their masters like cattle and treated worse than animals. With the passage of time, this evil tradition has died down but its remnants still linger in many dark corners of the civilized and uncivilised world. There are institutions and research groups that regularly study the phenomenon and sensitise the world towards the complete abolition of this abominable practice. Walk Free Foundation (WFF), one of the many campaign groups working on this issue, publishes an annual study on the prevalence of slavery around the world.

    Bonded labour has been outlawed in Pakistan and most other affected countries in line with UN conventions on human rights. However, according to the 2014 Global Slavery Index, 2,058,200 people are enslaved in Pakistan. The WFF Index places Pakistan at third position in a list of 167 countries where the problem of human slavery is most severe. After India and China, Pakistan is considered to have the largest number of people living in conditions that can be described as belonging to modern-day slavery. It is reported that the combined number of such people found in India, Pakistan and Thailand are estimated to equal almost half of nearly 36 million people trapped in slavery globally.

    The report accompanying the slavery index identifies debt bondage to be the most common factor creating conditions of slavery. It says: “The provinces of Punjab and Sindh are hotspots of bonded labour, which is mainly found in the brick making, agriculture and carpet weaving industries. While official statistics are not available, recently it was estimated that the brick kiln industry employs around 4.5 million people across the country.” Bonded labour, also called debt bondage, is defined as a form of slavery by the Abolition of Forced Labour Commission 1957 and a form of forced labour under the International Labour Organisation (ILO) Forced Labour Convention 1930. A person becomes a bonded labourer when he or she takes or is tricked into taking a loan. Subsequently, the person is forced to work long hours for little or no pay often for seven days a week, in order to repay the debt. Sometimes the debt is never repaid and simply passes from one generation to the next. Intimidation and violence are used to prevent people escaping from this form of slavery.

    The United Nations estimates that there are millions enslaved as bonded labourers in Pakistan. Ironically, these people live in a country that has several laws specifically outlawing bonded labour but none of them of them are enforced. In Pakistan, bonded labour has long been a feature in brick kilns, carpet industries, agriculture, fisheries, stone brick crushing, shoe making, power looms and refuse sorting. Some civil society organisations estimated that eight million children are kept as bonded labour in Pakistan but these figures are outdated and no recent figures are available to determine the number of children who are working as bonded labour. However, the ILO estimates a minimum of 11.7 million people forced into bonded labour in the Asia-Pacific region while over one million men, women and children are employed as bonded labourers in brick kilns. Most of them are in debt bondage. The phenomenon of bonded labour is very common in the brick kiln sector, in all the provinces of Pakistan, with a majority of brick kilns located in Punjab. The workers in brick-kilns live and work in crowded conditions, with little or no access to basic nutrition, clean water and general hygiene. They are also exposed to pollutants, dust and disease.

    Pakistan has ratified a number of international covenants and conventions that proscribe slavery, forced labour and debt-bondage. The Bonded Labour System (Abolition) Act of 1992 was introduced with the avowed purpose of abolishing the bonded labour system, with a view of preventing the economic and physical exploitation of the labour class in the country and for matters connected to it. Moreover, the Constitution of Pakistan, in Article 14, explains the dignity of man as inviolable and states that all citizens are equal before law and are entitled to equal protection of the law under Article 25. Article 11(2), in order to uphold this spirit, prohibits all forms of bonded labour and trafficking in human beings. Article 11(1) further states that slavery is non-existent and forbidden, and that no law should permit or facilitate its introduction in Pakistan in any form. Article 9 of Pakistan’s Constitution is also relevant in that it states that no person can be deprived of liberty save in accordance with the law. Article 15, dealing with freedom of movement, gives every citizen the right to remain in, and subject to any reasonable restriction imposed by the law in the public interest, enter and move freely throughout Pakistan and to reside and settle anywhere. However, bonded labour in Pakistan is widespread.

    While talking to Raja Abbas, the president of the Association of Network for Community Empowerment working for the rights of brick kiln workers, said: “We need to urge provincial governments to practically enforce the Bonded Labour System (Abolition) Act 1992, prepare provincial plans of action and take all other steps necessary to end this slavery.” He also said: “We demand uniform enforcement of the minimum wage for all bonded workers, acceptance of their right to hold CNICs and derive due benefit from old age benefit and social security schemes. I believe that the provincial governments must ensure that while implementing Article 25-A and extending facilities for compulsory free education to children, they will pay special attention to the rights and needs of the children of workers, especially bonded labour. Women, children and members of vulnerable communities among the bonded workers live under double jeopardy and the authorities must pay special attention to their security, welfare and economic rights.”

    I am of the view that the Bonded Labour System (Abolition) Act 1992 should be applied and amended further to penalise land lords maintaining bonded labour. Moreover, brick kiln workers should be recognised by law as workers and as citizens of Pakistan. Many brick kiln workers do not have legal documents such as identity cards and birth certificates. Without birth certificates their children cannot go to school because they cannot complete the admission documents and, when they grow up, they cannot get identity cards because, to get one, they need a birth certificate. And so the cycle continues.

    Different stakeholders have to understand the size and scope of this problem, contributing factors and existing response so that more effective action can be taken to end such brutal forms of human exploitation.

    Pashto poet Ameer Hamza Shinwari - A slow death for poetry









    The news was buried somewhere deep in the pages of the newspaper and really it was surprising that it had been reported at all.
    Against the blood and flesh deaths that take up the front and the back pages; this one represents the death of memory and of poetry.
    On Wednesday, February 19, a convening was held at the Pashto Department of the University of Peshawar, whose campus has been riven with extremism over the past several years. The solemn men gathered to commemorate the Pashto poet Ameer Hamza Shinwari, a mystic and a visionary who was born in Landi Kotal and wrote about love, at a time when such things were possible.
    Unsurprisingly, like so many other memories that do not fit into Pakistan’s ultra purified present, the legacy of Hamza Baba is being erased from the lore of the land.
    The scholars gathered in Peshawar this week, lamented just that. The literary center built in Landi Kotal to commemorate the poet’s legacy is being lost to neglect and disrepair, unable to host even the annual poetry gathering that used to mark Hamza Baba’s memory.
    Set against the craggy hills whose barrenness has become synonymous with only gunfire and grenades; the center has long been abandoned.
    Now, an apt metaphor for the loss of poetry and literary life in the country, it stands at the brink of death. The scholars who lament its passing and its promise, have urged the Government to take it over, but then, can a Government so unable to save itself, worshippers at mosques or children at schools, save poetry, rescue a literary legacy?
    These are questions we do cannot answer in Pakistan.
    Hamza Baba was born in 1907 and lived until 1994, writing many collections of verse and over 40 books. As a young man, he dreamt of writing stories that would become movies, the very first was an ode to love, the script for the Pashto rendition of Laila and Majnu.
    In his youth, Hamza Baba joined the Chistia Sufi order and his poetry reflected a syncretic blend of Sufi mysticism and Pashtunwali. After the creation of Pakistan, Hamza Baba set his pen to produce narratives of the new country, writing hundreds of plays that were performed on the then nascent Radio Pakistan. He was, at one point, awarded the Pride of Performance Award by the Government of Pakistan for his services to the literary vigour of the country.
    Those days are gone. Hamza Baba is dead and the literary complex that tried to embed his legacy in the restive and war torn soil of Khyber stands crumbling.
    It is the only such structure in the Federally Administered Tribal Areas, and even in its sad state still used by over a hundred poets in the region.
    In a country where poetry is fast synonymous with heresy there is little hope of rescue. Four years ago, in July 2011 Hamza Baba’s grave was attacked by the Taliban; its already humble ramparts ravaged by grenades. It has never been repaired.
    Dead or alive, forgotten and buried away, poets’ even ones long gone like Hamza Baba are targets.
    Killing them once is not enough, their graves and their legacies it has been decided, will be annihilated again and again to insure a complete destruction; a final forgetting, an imagined purification.