Saturday, October 31, 2020

Opinion | In Erdogan and Imran Khan’s Hypocritical War on ‘anti-Muslim’ Blasphemy, the Body Count Rises



By Kunwar Khuldune Shahid
 @khuldune 
In the wake of an extremist Muslim’s beheading of a French teacher who showed his pupils cartoons of the Prophet Muhammed, part of his class on free speech, French President Emmanuel Macron offered a staunch defense of free speech, and the right to publish those caricatures. The murdered teacher, Samuel Paty, has now been joined by three more victims, killed in or near a Nice church, including one whose throat was cut.
And who has taken center stage in the Muslim world’s response? Two so-called champions of selective, often hypocritical, outrage against ‘Islamophobia.'
The Islamist populists leading the charge are Pakistan’s Imran Khan, and Turkey’s Recep Tayyip Erdogan. And their favored rhetorical strategy is to insist on a disturbing equivalence between Holocaust denial and blasphemy.
As the movement to boycott France accelerates in many Muslim countries, Erdogan assessed that Macron needs "mental treatment." That prompted France to recall its ambassador from Turkey. Imran Khan accused the French president of "deliberately provoking Muslims" as Islamabad summoned the France ambassador for a dressing down.
Angst over lack of "freedom of belief" and "minority rights" is indeed pretty rich coming from Turkey and Pakistan, the two countries currently leading the overheated Islamist rhetoric. However, it is their needless, and disturbing, equivalence between blasphemy against Islam and the Holocaust that is especially mindboggling – and yet strikingly common in their discourse.
While urging the boycott of French goods, Erdogan invoked the Holocaust and equated France’s policies with Nazi Germany, saying that Muslims in Europe are now being subjected to a "lynch campaign similar to that against Jews before World War II."
Imran Khan meanwhile wrote a public letter to Mark Zuckerberg urging him to ban ‘Islamophobic’ content on Facebook, again using Holocaust denial as an analogy.
He noted Facebook "rightly" bans "any posting that criticises or questions the Holocaust, the culmination of the Nazi pogrom of the Jews in Germany and across Europe" and that "today we are seeing a similar pogrom against Muslims in many parts of the world," and asks for a "similar ban [to that on Holocaust denial] on Islamophobia and hate against Islam."
If the Facebook CEO wants to do due diligence on the consistency of Khan’s call to delegitimize extremism and its shills, he should start with Khan’s recent speech eulogizing Osama Bin Laden as a "martyr" of Islam. If there is anything more preposterous than Khan’s frequent and conveniently myopic lectures on Islamophobia, it is often their timing.
The day the Pakistani premier was expressing outrage against Charlie Hebdo’s cartoons at the United Nations General Assembly, a man of Pakistani origin launched a terror attack targeting the French publication’s former offices.
Khan’s sermon attacking Macron came a day after yet another Hindu temple was desecrated and vandalized in Pakistan’s Nagarparkar region, and only 46 years after the Ahmadi Muslim community was defined as heretical in Pakistan’s constitution – an act of collective discrimination that Khan has addressed with full-scale appeasement.
Even so, where Khan is perhaps unaware, or in denial, about Islamist abuses in Pakistan, he has been consciously and steadfastly over the years, drawing parallels between blasphemy against Islam and the genocide of Jews. In his letter to Zuckerberg, Khan reiterated a moral equivalence between banning Holocaust denial and censoring criticism of Islam. Days later, Khan doubled down on his Holocaust analogy in a public letter to Muslim states: he noted many European states had banned any "questioning of the Holocaust" but not "mockery" of Mohammed.
Unfortunately, for pieces of writing ostensibly aiming to argue for equal treatment of religious communities, Khan’s letters often betrayed bias against Jews, not to mention belittling of their genocide.
Before we even begin to unpack the horrors of juxtaposing the industrial massacre of six million people and caricatures, one should note how Khan’s reframing of Holocaust denial as "questioning or criticizing" is bizarrely watered down, especially when compared with the adjectives reserved for protection of Islam and Muslims: denial, extreme, hate, abominable, violent, abuse, vilification or, indeed, phobia.
Similar soft revisionism can be seen in the equation of Indian military occupation in Kashmir, or the Bharatiya Janata Party-led fueling of anti-Muslim hatred, with the extermination and ethnic cleansing of Jews.
Regrettably, it is hard to find a global Muslim leader relating to the Holocaust simply as a crime against Jews that should never be repeated. Khan is just the latest to weaponize it in reference to victimization of Muslims, a tactic more often used by both Islamists and many in the Western left to describe Israel’s oppressive policies towards the Palestinians.
In his letter to Zuckerberg, Khan appears to be arguing that the Holocaust is somehow privileged over blasphemy against Islam, implying some sort of lobbying, if not a downright conspiracy.
This is in line with Khan’s rehashing of anti-Semitic tropes about an Israel lobby – conflated in domestic popular media with “Jewish lobby" – destabilizing Pakistan, which he reinvoked as recently as last Friday when he accused the opposition parties of being the third party in an "axis of evil" alongside India and Israel.
The grand paradox here, of course, is the fact that Khan, owing to his first marriage to Jemima Goldsmith, is regularly accused of being a "Jewish agent." And yet the Pakistani premier prefers validating anti-Semitic conspiracy theories instead of ever uttering a single condemnation of any of the, far too frequent, sweeping statements blaming "world Jewry" for any of the ills afflicting Pakistan or the Muslim world, or of the clerics who lead calls in Pakistani mosques for the destruction of the Jews.
Ironically, much of the targeting of Muslims that Khan’s Facebook letter highlights – ranging from blaming minorities for the spread of COVID-19 to discriminatory religionist laws – are far more prevalent in Pakistan. Amidst all the talk of Islamophobia, Pakistan remains the only country in the world that actually criminalizes the recitation of Quran, and the Islamic call to prayer, when they deny the Ahmadiyya sect the right to self-identify as Muslims.
And despite the egregious invocation of the Holocaust and its suffering, the Khan-led Pakistan, like other Muslim-majority states, will never condemn what is the closest approximation today to the Nazis’ concentration camps – the "re-education camps" established by China in which one million Uighur Muslims are currently detained. Indeed, Khan vocally defends those concentration camps as a "non-issue."
Pakistan and Turkey’s use of the Holocaust for point-scoring, and the implied justification of violent reactions to "anti-Islamic" blasphemy, underlines a more general failure of Muslim leaders to understand the basic concept of free speech, or even their own duplicitous claims of “double standards.” Any Western state, including France, which “allows” blasphemy against Islam also permits the same against other religions. Instead of taunting parallels between Holocaust denial and caricatures of Muslim prophets, a more valid global comparison would focus on blasphemy laws, which exist across 77 countries, and what the impact of censoring blasphemy has on rights and lives.
Blasphemy is a capital offense only in Muslim-majority countries. 12 Muslim-majority states have established the death penalty with 20 others establishing prison sentences. And lest one thought the idea was to protect all people of faith – these offenses are all Islam-specific, and the laws do not stipulate similar punishments for sacrilege against other religions.
Elsewhere, even countries that have an outdated form of a blasphemy law, like Australia, Canada or Finland, have a more or less redundant version which, importantly, is still equally applicable for all religions.
Furthermore, those conjuring these absurd comparisons seem to ignore how opposition to Holocaust denial has never triggered violence. Nowhere is it suggested that the provocation of Holocaust denial justifies violence, knife attacks or murder. Nowhere is violence or the death sentence codified for denying the genocide of Jews.
Compare that to the open incitement of another "leader" of the Muslim world's fight against Islamophobia, ex-Malaysian prime minister Mahathir Mohamad, who self-identifies as a "proud antisemite," tweeted Wednesday that "the Muslims have the right to punish the French" for being blamed for violence, and continued: "Muslims have the right to be angry and kill millions of French people for the massacres of the past."
The irony couldn't be clearer: only last year, Mahathir was rhapsodizing about free speech, but for antisemites: "When you say, ‘No, you cannot say this. You cannot be anti-Semitic’ then there is no more free speech," he declared, and followed up by querying how many Jews actually died in the Holocaust.
In any case, Imran Khan and others regularly miscontrue why Holocaust denial has been criminalized in countries like Germany, when they suggest it is a form of pandering to ‘safeguard the delicate/politically significant sentiments of Jews.’ But the ban on denial is actually part of legislation banning the denial of Nazi crimes in a bid to help ensure they’re never repeated where they were instigated.
Had Pakistan accepted its own genocide of Bengalis in 1971, or Turkey its genocide in Armenia, their leaders today might have better standing, and if they had been apprised of the notion of hypocrisy, they might have known better than to shout ‘Islamophobia’ amidst Islamist abuses in their own country.
Indeed, it is Pakistan and Turkey’s glorification of Islamist vandalizers of Hindu temples and Ottoman massacres that have contributed to the rise of populist, and self-unaware, leaders like Khan and Erdogan. For freedom of expression to be universally applied, Holocaust denial itself should be decriminalized. People should be free to be ignorant of the most gruesome horrors of history, even one of the gravest crimes committed against humanity. If nothing else, this might prevent self-appointed global Muslim leaders from expediently equating the denial of the Holocaust with "global anti-Muslim persecution," a narrative mired in contention. The truth is if these Muslim leaders fail to see the duplicity of their demands for the exclusive protection of Islam from satire, their own boosting of bigotry, their equation of blasphemy with the genocide of Jews and their implicit endorsement of the righteousness of violent retaliation, then there is no way they should ever be given any veto power over free speech.
We can’t ever have confidence in the critical faculties of "moral" leaders who, in the aftermath of the killings of cartoonists, can only bring themselves to condemn the cartoons.
https://www.haaretz.com/world-news/.premium-body-count-rises-in-turkey-and-pakistan-s-hypocritical-war-on-anti-muslim-offense-1.9268714

Pakistan still obsessing over Abhinandan. How about an update on Israeli pilot Army ‘caught’

 

In Pakistan, PML-N leader's remarks on minister Shah Mehmood Qureshi are a more serious threat to national security than minister Fawad Chaudhry claiming a terror attack.

The year of the rat continues to be obsessed with the year that was, 2019. That was when the enemy pilot Abhinandan came, had chai and left. He left, but like any jilted ex, the conversations continue about why he left us. He didn’t say, “It’s me, not you”. But for Pakistanis, it still remains an unfinished agenda even in 2020, the year that is actually all about being Modi’s yaar and Pakistan’s ghaddar.

This is Pakistan in a nutshell.

On Wednesday, Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) leader Ayaz Sadiq shared on the floor of the National Assembly how the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) government was panicking to release Abhinandan Varthaman because it feared an attack from the Indian military. The conversation referred to a parliamentary briefing held after the capture of the Indian pilot in February 2019, an exchange that Prime Minister Imran Khan was not a part of even as Army chief General Qamar Javed Bajwa was present. Sadiq explained that Foreign Minister Shah Mehmood Qureshi was jittery with a sweaty forehead when he told those present at the briefing, “Khuda ka wasta hai ab isko jane dein (for god’s sake let him go),” referring to Abhinandan. According to Sadiq, India was going to attack Pakistan at 9pm.

Hum bhi hain josh mein

It was as if Qureshi would turn into a pumpkin if Abhinandan wasn’t released before 9pm. Tea was still fantastic, 9pm or 9am. There is still no news on the fictitious Israeli pilot that Pakistan caught. Probably he is still having tea somewhere here.

Shocking revelation? Not really. The mention of an Indian attack was already made by PM Imran Khan during his address to the Assembly on February 28. He had said that there were fears India might launch a missile attack on Pakistan, but the situation was later defused.

What came as a real shocker was Science and Technology Minister Fawad Chaudhry’s response to Ayaz Sadiq. In josh-e-khitabat, the minister went on to claim Pulwama terror attack, which killed 40 Indian soldiers, as a huge victory of Pakistan under the leadership of Imran Khan. “Humne Hindustan ko ghus ke maara hai (we hit India in their home). Our success in Pulwama was the success of the nation,” Chaudhry said, berating the PML-N leader.

Chaudhry just fell short of breath, otherwise the flow in which he was, he might as well have taken credit for crashing planes into the World Trade Centre on 9/11. It was only after he had made all the confessions that he thought he should modify his boast a bit, which is what he did: “Pulwama ke baad humne ghus ke maara” — the modification being ‘after Pulwama’.

Priorities you & I won’t understand

The minister’s ramblings were astounding and could have serious repercussions for Pakistan. But what woke the military spokesman up from deep slumber was Ayaz Sadiq and not Fawad Chaudhry. Even repeated allegations of political engineering against Qamar Bajwa by former prime minister Nawaz Sharif didn’t sprung DG-ISPR into action. But here he was. Now a pro at rejecting stuff from political leaders, Babar Iftikhar held a presser to reject the statement that Abhinandan was released owing to perceived threat of an Indian attack.

Only in Pakistan are the remarks on an opposition leader a more serious threat to national security than a sitting minister’s 60 seconds of claiming and celebrating a terrorist attack. This is the reason why PTI ministers are taken as seriously as they are around the world. And the same set of ministers now want a criminal charge against Ayaz Sadiq. Him revealing that Qureshi’s legs were shaking and he was sweating is tantamount to outing State secrets?

A campaign to brand Sadiq a ‘traitor’ is now on, with posters coming up on the streets of Lahore. Sadiq is shown wearing an Abhinandan-like moustache with both Modi and the Indian pilot in the background. ‘Mir Jaffar, Mir Sadiq…Ayaz Sadiq’ is the tagline.

The excuse for the extreme reaction is to point towards “how Indian media is having a field day with Ayaz Sadiq’s statement”. But the same people choose to look the other way when Indian media is amplifying Fawad Chaudhry’s remarks and bringing more attention. If coverage in Indian media is the parameter of bringing bad name to the country, then where does PM Imran Khan stand over his several interviews and conclaves that he attended in India, where he said the most controversial things? Where does he stand over the Indian media’s rather extensive coverage of PTI’s dharnas when he was in the opposition?

Imran Khan’s simple rule

The entire episode reflects the simmering tension between the PTI and the opposition parties ever since the anti-government protests began. It is clear that when confronted with the ghaddari (traitor) allegations, the leaders of PML-N and even other parties reply in the same coin. If the previous PML-N government will be blamed for Kulbhushan Jadhav’s case in the International Court of Justice (ICJ), its leaders will hit back with PTI going out of the way and making concessions for Jadhav now.

The world may have moved onto dealing with more pressing concerns brought about by the Covid-19 pandemic, or bothering about who will be the next president of the United States. But what matters the most to the government of Imran Khan is the continuous labelling of his political opponents as pawns of India. In Khan dreamland, whether he’s in opposition or in power, his opponents remain traitors. He vehemently believed that whenever Nawaz Sharif was in trouble, tension along Pakistan’s borders and terror attacks increased. Now as prime minister, he still gives out certificates of working with ‘Israeli and Indian lobby’ to the opposition. For Imran Khan, it works like: heads I win, tails you lose.

https://theprint.in/opinion/letter-from-pakistan/pakistan-still-obsessing-over-abhinandan-how-about-an-update-on-israeli-pilot-army-caught/534554/


In light of Pakistan's criticism of France, leader Marine Le Pen calls for ban on Pakistan immigration

Namrata Agarwal
French leader Marine Le Pen urged to impose a ban on Pakistani immigration amidst critical comments by Pakistan leaders on France. Calling it as a threat to the country, the leader of the National Rally Party called for a ban on Pakistani immigration .


 Taking to Twitter she wrote (in French which roughly translates to): "In view of the new ultra-violent demonstrations today in #Bangladesh (demonstrators who called to behead our ambassador), and #Pakistan , I call for an immediate moratorium on immigration from these countries, in the name of national security. MLP." Recently, France witnessed gruesome murders after President Emmanuel Macron defended the right to caricature the Prophet Mohammed.

 It has witnessed two knife attacks, one in Nice in which three people were killed at a church, and another in Avignon, in which the attacker was killed by the police. While, a guard at the French consulate at the Saudi city of Jeddah was attacked.
https://zeenews.india.com/india/in-light-of-pakistans-criticism-of-france-leader-marine-le-pen-calls-for-ban-on-pakistan-immigration-2321336.html

Turkey and Pakistan's campaign to boycott French products backfire as Saudi Arabia steps in

Manish Shukla
French President Emmanuel Macron's stand against Islamist terrorism has led to a new geopolitical tussle among countries like Turkey, Pakistan and Saudi Arabia.
The temperament displayed by French President Emmanuel Macron to fight the radical Islamist terrorism after the brutal murder of teacher Samuel Paty and the outrage by the French citizens over the incident has led to a new geopolitical tussle.
In response, Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan attacked Macron and said, “The person in charge of France has lost his way. He goes on about Erdogan all day. Look at yourself first and where you are going…he is a case and he really must be checked up.”
Turkey also launched an aggressive campaign to boycott French goods from its markets.
In a show of support to Turkey's campaign, Pakistani Prime Minister Imran Khan tweeted that Macron chose “to encourage Islamophobia by attacking Islam rather than the terrorists” adding that Macron chose “to deliberately provoke Muslims, including own citizens.” Recently, boycott France products was a top trend in Pakistan. It joined Turkey in attacking France and Pakistanis have been aggressively trending several hashtags over social media platforms, urging people to boycott French products, abusing the French President, and threatening French citizens.
Besides Pakistani citizens staying all over the world launched a global campaign to boycott French products. Many prominent Pakistani Twitter handles, with a blue- tick, spat venom on the French President and urged Muslims worldwide to boycott products of the country.Editor of a prominent Pakistani daily ‘The News’, Ansar Abbasi urged the Islamic fraternity of the world to protest against France against the ‘shameful’ attack on Muslims by using the hashtag #MacronGoneMad.Responding to the boycott campaign, Macron tweeted, “We will not give in, ever. We respect all differences in a spirit of peace. We do not accept hate speech and defend reasonable debate. We will always be on the side of human dignity and universal values.”
It is believed that by launching the strongest attack on the French government, Erdogan would be able to project himself as the ‘Messiah’ of Muslim Ummah and leader of the ‘Caliphate’. Observers see this as Erdogan’s efforts to encash the opportunity to challenge Saudi Arabia's leadership of Islamic world.
Unlike Turkey and Pakistan, the supreme body of Muslim countries, the Organisation for Islamic Cooperation (OIC) condemned the act of gruesome killing of the French teacher, besides expressing its concerns on ‘ongoing practice of running satirical caricatures depicting the Prophet Muhammad'.Taking a divergent route from the balanced approach of the OIC, Turkey-led Islamic block unilaterally attacked the French government and sympathised with the attacker.Turkey and Pakistan's aggression was not taken in good taste by Saudi Arabia, which has been a constant target of Turkish President Erdogan in his efforts to displace Saudi as the leader of Islamic world.Citizens of Saudi Arabia have, in fact, launched a massive campaign to boycott Turkish goods. Saudi shops and supermarkets have boycotted Turkish goods and replaced Turkish items with the Greek ones. Expressing solidarity with Greece on Turkish aggression as well as denoting the availability of Greek products in their stores, Saudi traders hung Greek flags outside their establishments.
The Saudi citizens have taken up a comprehensive campaign against Turkey on the basis of three principles – No investment, no imports and no tourism. It is striking to note that the campaign has not been launched by the Saudi Government, rather it is driven by the common public sentiments of the Saudi citizens.
Besides boycotting local products made in Turkey, Saudi citizens are also boycotting the products of international brands produced in Turkey. Such a boycott might turn Turkey into a hostile investment destination and thereby compelling companies to pull out their investments from the country.
Saudi Arabia has been one of the biggest markets for import of Turkish products. Besides, Turkey also uses the country as a transit point to trade its goods elsewhere in the region. Hence, the boycott by Saudi citizens, if continued for long, might prove costly for Turkey.
Current developments suggest that efforts of Turkey and Pakistan might have begun to backfire. The strong resolve of the French President and the retaliation by Saudi citizens might impact the economies of both the countries, which are already not in a very good state. Besides economic and diplomatic losses for Turkey, the tussle on boycott campaign is also going to inflict huge strategic and diplomatic losses for Pakistan.
Pakistan's desperate jump at Erdogan’s anti-French rhetoric and unwarranted threats from the Pakistani leadership and elites might have added to the displeasure of Saudi Arabia, which has been disgruntled on Pakistan's support of unilaterally projecting Erdogan as the tallest leader of the Ummah. Besides, Pakistan might have found a new antagonist in another world superpower — France!
Nevertheless, the tussle between pro-France and pro-Turkey countries is certainly going to be intensified in the next few days, throwing reflections on the emerging geopolitical dynamics of the world.
https://zeenews.india.com/world/turkey-and-pakistans-campaign-to-boycott-french-products-backfires-as-saudi-arabia-steps-in-2321103.html

Friday, October 30, 2020

Persian Music Video - Ahmad Zahir - "Khuda Bowad Yaret"

Video Report - #NayaDaur Arzoo Raja Case, And State Of Pakistani Minorities

Video - #Pakistan - #ArzooRaja| Women's charter demands| How To End The Culture of Intolerance

Chairman PPP congratulates the successful candidates of the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) elections

 

Chairman Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) Bilawal Bhutto Zardari has congratulated the successful candidates according to the unofficial results of the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) elections.

Abdul Latif Afridi of Independent Group of lawyers, also known as the late Asma Jahangir group, and Ahmad Shahzad Farooq were respectively elected as President SCBA and General Secretary along with other office-bearers. Peoples Lawyers Forum had supported the Independent Group.

Bilawal Bhutto Zardari hoped that the new SCBA body will struggle for supremacy of the Constitution and law to strengthen democracy and Parliament. He further said that the lawyer fraternity has always been with the democratic forces of the country, and this alliance shall always be in place.


https://www.ppp.org.pk/pr/24001/

Christian girl, 13, is kidnapped by 44-year-old man in Pakistan and forced to convert to Islam and marry him

Arzoo Raja was abducted from her home in Karachi on October 13, activists say.Two days later her 44-year-old 'husband' produced a marriage certificate .Protests have broken out after a Pakistani court upheld the marriage's validity.
A 13-year-old Christian girl was kidnapped in Pakistan and forced to marry a 44-year-old man who made her convert to Islam, campaigners say.
Arzoo Raja was abducted from her home in Karachi on October 13, and two days later her 'husband' produced a marriage certificate saying she was 18 and had converted to Islam.
The case has led to protests in Karachi and Lahore but a Pakistani court has upheld the marriage after her husband claimed she had converted of her own free will.
Arzoo tried to run to her mother during the court hearing but her husband held her in a tight grip to stop her from leaving, it is alleged.
Arzoo's father Raja said that his daughter had been abducted from the family home in Karachi's Railway Colony after her parents went to work.
When police contacted the family two days later they said that the 'husband' had already obtained a marriage certificate, according to a Christian group called the Centre for Legal Aid, Assistance and Settlement (CLAAS).
'Very often young girls are threatened into giving statements to the court saying they have married and converted to Islam of their own free will,' said CLAAS UK director Nasir Saeed.
'It is a very sensitive matter for Pakistani Christians but sadly it is all falling on the deaf ears of the politicians and the authorities.
'It is sad as the Pakistani police and courts have failed to respect their own laws, as well international standards, which are continuing to be ignored especially in forced conversion and forced marriage cases even in the higher courts.'
Arzoo allegedly had her name changed to Arzoo Fatima and a judge claimed that she had converted to Islam of her own free will.
At a court hearing, the husband allegedly 'held on tightly to her arm' to stop her reaching her mother, who was not allowed to meet her daughter.
The certificate said she was 18, but the family has a birth certificate showing she is 13, according to a Catholic organisation called Aid to the Church in Need.
The charity says that Arzoo's parents have lost their jobs and been threatened by kidnappers since their daughter disappeared.
According to figures from the campaign group Girls Not Brides, around 21 per cent of girls in Pakistan are married before the age of 18. The group says that traditionalist customs and religious views mean some families believe they should 'marry off their daughters once they reach puberty'.
Low levels of education are also described as 'both a cause and a consequence' of child marriage,' it says.
In 2017, Pakistan's government tried to crack down on child marriage by imposing prison sentences up to 10 years for offenders.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8896671/Christian-girl-13-kidnapped-44-year-old-man-Pakistan.html

Thursday, October 29, 2020

Music Video - INNA - Yalla

How Mohammed bin Salman is quietly enabling an Israeli axis in the Arab world

Madawi al-Rasheed
Using Saudi influence and the promise of financial rewards, MBS can continue to bring more Arab countries into the normalisation fold.

The claims made by Israeli-American billionaire Haim Saban that Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman's reluctance to rush into normalisation with Israel was due to his fear that Iran, Qatar or "his own people" would kill him, must be taken with a pinch of salt.

In truth, MBS fears murder in the palace more than murder by the people, or for that matter by Iran or Qatar. His nightmare scenario is to rule as a king who has shattered royal consensus and humiliated a bunch of royal rivals.  

MBS is not Egypt's Anwar Sadat, assassinated in 1981 after signing the first historic peace treaty with Israel

The Saudi crown prince will not rush into going public over his relations with Israel if he can keep them under the table. Why should he sign a controversial agreement with Israel when the costs could be far higher than maintaining a secret alliance?

The fear of being killed by Iran, Qatar or his own people is unfounded, as none of those three are constituencies contemplating or capable of carrying out an assassination.  

MBS is not Egypt's Anwar Sadat, assassinated in 1981 after he'd signed the first historic peace treaty with Israel, the Camp David Agreement, in 1979, shocking many Arabs, including Saudis. The late Saudi King Fahd, who staged a momentary boycott of Egypt to please an angry Saudi constituency and the wider Arab world, soon reversed his policy and worked hard to bring Egypt back into the Arab fold. 

Today the situation is different. The Saudi regime in general - and MBS in particular - can be more useful to the cause of normalisation with Israel without having a relationship in the open that would see the Israeli flag raised in Riyadh. MBS can work as a conduit, a facilitator, a behind-the-scenes agent, who would use Saudi influence and the promise of financial rewards to bring more Arab countries into the fold of an Israeli axis in the region.

The Saudi umbrella 

So far, the UAE, Bahrain and Sudan are well placed to pursue normalisation under a Saudi umbrella, without MBS making a move which might be seen as an explicit endorsement of US President Donald Trump and his campaign for re-election, with polls currently showing Democratic candidate Joe Biden as favourite for the White House.

 Further, MBS will hesitate to join the new axis if he and his father, King Salman, can continue to make noises about respecting defunct Arab peace initiatives, such as the one announced by King Fahd in the 1980s. 

Moreover, while awaiting the right moment to go public about normalisation, the crown prince can bring more Arab countries into the normalisation fold, thus winning more favour in Washington while appearing to support Palestinian rights.

At the same time, MBS can continue to deploy his media resources to erode Arab public support for the Palestinians, until the critical point is reached when Saudi normalisation becomes a fait accompli that would not cost him his life or undermine the legitimacy of the Saudi regime. 

  Palestinians burn pictures depicting US President, Abu Dhabi Crown Prince and Saudi Arabia's Crown Prince during a protest against the UAE deal with Israel in Ramallah on 15 August (Reuters)
Palestinians burn pictures of the US president, Abu Dhabi's crown prince and MBS during a protest against the UAE deal with Israel in Ramallah on 15 August 2020 (Reuters)

Trump and Israel will have to wait to see whether MBS’s campaign to erode Palestinian rights bears fruit. Trump may be out of office soon, but MBS looks like he will outlast him. If MBS does have legitimate fears for his life, then the danger is truly not from the three constituencies that he announced to Haim Saban.

Palace coup

The true threat to MBS comes from within his own family, rather than from his "own people" (by which he must mean the Saudi people, who have never assassinated a Saudi royal). Historically, any assassinations in the kingdom have been carried out by members of the House of Saud. 

MBS can continue deploying his media resources to erode Arab public support for the Palestinians

Since the 19th century, slain Saudi princes and kings have been killed by a brother, uncle or nephew. The last murder in the palace, in 1975, was that of King Faisal, shot dead by his young nephew, also called Faisal. Neither the Palestinian cause nor any other cause were behind such murders.

They were simply family homicides, motivated by revenge, treachery and power struggles within the royal household. It is this that MBS truly fears, rather than what Saban claimed the crown prince had told him. 

And MBS has many reasons to fear an assassination from his own relatives rather than being murdered over his abandoning of the Palestinian cause or the normalising of relations with Israel. Since MBS came to power in 2017, he has pursued a policy of detention of potential rival princes.

So far he has not executed his royal critics (although the execution of peaceful protesters is on the rise), but perhaps it won’t be long before MBS considers eliminating his rivals altogether. He has shattered royal consensus and pursued policies that undermine the regime as a whole rather than simply his own chances of becoming king.

A prince who believes that MBS is a danger for the whole family is yet to emerge. When and if that happens, then the stakes would rise considerably. 

Media brainwashing

Of course, many in Saudi Arabia continue to oppose normalisation with Israel. But those are gradually being indoctrinated into accepting such normalisation with the help of the Saudi media. Frankly, most Saudis have more urgent matters to worry about.

MBS has many reasons to fear an assassination from his own relatives rather than being murdered over his abandoning of the Palestinian cause

From their declining living standards to fears of power struggles within the royal household, Saudis are beginning to feel the insecurity of their own lives under a regime that has plundered their wealth and repressed them, depriving them of a decent life in one of the richest countries in the world.

MBS has yet to reconcile with his own family and secure the throne amid the current widespread insecurity in the kingdom.

MBS’s "own people" are neither assassins nor treacherous. They simply need a decent life and a say over how their country is run.

The crown prince will never listen to their needs, but his own relatives may become impatient when he finally becomes king. 

https://www.middleeasteye.net/opinion/saudi-arabia-mohammed-bin-salman-quietly-enabling-israel-axis-arab-world

France brought Jihad on itself, now has some tough decisions to make – former anti-terrorism

 

A spate of stabbing attacks are the result of France’s failed experiment with multiculturalism, former UK counterterrorism chief Chris Philipps told RT. When the liberal West and Islamic East clash, he said, violence follows.

“I do believe that France and the West brought a lot of this on themselves,” Philipps told RT on Thursday. “They’ve invited people to come to their country and allowed people to come to their country who’ve no thought process of eventually assimilating.”

“French culture, you either accept it or you don’t, and these people clearly haven’t,” he continued.

Earlier, a knife-wielding attacker killed three people in a church in Nice, police in Avignon shot another knifeman dead, and another alleged terrorist attack was foiled near a church in Sartrouville, near Paris. Additionally, police in Saudi Arabia arrested a man for stabbing a guard outside the French consulate in Jeddah.

French President Emmanuel Macron called the Nice attacker an “Islamist terrorist,” and deployed troops to guard churches and schools. Just days earlier, Macron had vowed to clamp down on “the evil that is radical Islam,” after a teenage Muslim beheaded a teacher for showing his class a caricature of the Prophet Mohammed.

Macron’s army deployment may reassure the public in the short term, but Philipps said that it’s “pretty much impossible” to screen out potential future attackers, and harder again to deport or detain them, as in his experience in the UK, many suspects were British citizens.

“We’ve got 20 or 30 thousand people of concern in the UK. France probably has far more than that,” he explained. "If you go to Nice there’s a massive North African contingent there.” 

French media outlets have reported that the Nice attacker – who was shot and arrested by police – was a 21-year-old Tunisian migrant. Four years earlier, a Tunisian was behind the wheel of a 19-ton truck that plowed through crowds of people on the city’s iconic waterfront, killing 84 and injuring more than 400. France’s population is nearly nine percent Muslim, the highest percentage in any Western country. Of these 5.7 million Muslims, the percentage who harbor extreme views is unknown, but in 2016, three quarters of all suspected radicals on a government watch list were radical Islamists.

Philipps said that in his experience, he was surprised how many moderate Muslims see cartoons of the Prophet Mohammed as “extremely offensive” and understand “the idea of taking revenge.”

The core of the problem, he said, is the incompatibility of Islam with the liberal West. “When the cultures clash so much, and it leads to this kind of violence,” he said, governments need to “make some decisions” regarding the future of multiculturalism and open society.

While Philipps spoke in apocalyptic terms about the future of multicultural France, Muslim author and lawyer Asif Arif is more optimistic. The fight against terrorism, he told RT France, is “a long and hard war,” that “will not be fought with common arms.” 

Rather than deploy troops and close Islamic organizations, as Macron has done in recent days, Arif said that the French government should increase funding to counterterroism investigators and deploy intelligence agents to mosques and Muslim organizations to gather information and identify potential threats.

“We need these Muslim organizations to fight terrorism,” Arif concluded. “Stigmatization will never help.”

https://www.rt.com/news/504921-france-attacks-failed-integration/

China sets ‘pragmatic’ targets through 2035

By Wang Cong, Cao Siqi and Chen Qingqing 

 Nation aims for ‘big leaps’ in economy, technology.

With decisive progress in the past five years and a strategic victory against the COVID-19, top leadership of the Communist Part of China (CPC) on Thursday unveiled a steady and bright picture for the country's future, as it sets sweeping social and economic development goals for the next five to 15 years that aim to build the world's most populous nation into a modern socialist power in the economic, technological and other fields by 2035. 

In a wide-ranging communiqué released after the fifth plenary session of the 19th Central Committee of the CPC ended in Beijing, top officials conclude that China remains in a major strategic development period, citing "decisive achievements" in the past five years and "major strategic results" of the COVID-19 epidemic, and offered sweeping solutions in a wide range of areas, from economy, to security, and to governance.

While the communiqué projected confidence in China's development paths and prospects, certain targets, particularly in economic areas, reflected a cautious and pragmatic sentiment among top officials, given mounting domestic and external pressure on growth, while other goals such as greenhouse gas reductions underscored the country's determination to pursue high-quality growth and tackle global issues, experts said.

 
00:00:00 / 01:55

 
Sweeping targets
   

"Having deeply analyzed the profound and complex changes our country faces in its development, the plenary session believes that China's development remains in an important strategic period," the communiqué said, calling for strategic patience in overcoming challenges and striving for progress.

Among the key takeaways from the communiqué are sweeping targets sets for the 14th Five-Year Plan (2021-25) and long-range goals through the year 2035. Coming at a critical inflection point for China, the four-day meeting and the targets for the coming five to 15 years are essential steps in China's long-term goal for national rejuvenation. The 14th Five-Year Plan would also mark the start of the pursuit of the second centenary goal to build a modern socialist country. 

"Previously, we usually set five-year plans, but this time we mentioned the 'long-range goals for 2035' for the first time. The time span extended from five years to 15 years. That shows we have become more strategic," Yang Xuedong, a professor of political science at Tsinghua University, told the Global Times on Thursday.

Under the goals in the communiqué, China will achieve modern socialism by 2035. What that entails includes achieving "big leaps" in economic strength, technological prowess as well as overall national strength, the document said. Total economic output and urban and rural income will reach a "new level," and major breakthroughs would be made in core technologies.

"I think those targets are very pragmatic as they reflect our advantages and long-term development goals, as well as the many challenges we have to face," Tian Yun, vice director of the Beijing Economic Operation Association, told the Global Times on Thursday.

Though the document refrained from offering specific empirical targets, Tian said that those goals could mean that China would double its current GDP of around 100 trillion yuan in 2035, and double current per capita GDP of $10,000. "That would require a real GDP growth of around 3.5 percent annually; it is a big target but can be done if China's full potential is realized," he said.

In keeping with a decades-long tradition, the communiqué also included goals for the 14th Five-Year Plan. During the coming five-year period, China will aim for "new achievements" and "sustained and sound growth" based on improvements in quality. The domestic market will be further boosted and economic structure would be improved, it said.

In a breakaway from previous five-year plans, the 14th Five-Year Plan did not include an annual growth target. In the 13th Five-Year Plan, an annual growth target of around 6.5 percent, which, experts say, could be missed due to the COVID-19 epidemic.

That decision reflected the considerable risks and challenges the country is confronted with, including the COVID-19 pandemic, experts noted. 

The new five-year plan came at a critical juncture for the Chinese economy. Though China has effectively reined in the epidemic and embarked on a steady economic recovery path with a 4.9 percent growth in the third quarter in the year, the deadly virus continues to ravage across the world, which is already mired in rising trade and geopolitical tensions.

While the 6,200-word communiqué focused mostly on economic issues, it also touched on a long list of issues, including governance system, security, social fairness, education, healthcare, and environmental protection - all part of China's long-term strategy to build a modern socialist society. 

In security, the communiqué called for modernizing its military. On environmental protection, the communiqué said that China will continue to reduce carbon dioxide emissions after reaching a peak by 2035, which experts called a "bold" pledge that reflects China's determination to tackle climate and environment issues.  

Highlights of the fifth plenary session of the 19th CPC Central Committee Infographic: GT


 

Paths to success

The communiqué also outlined strategies and paths that China would take to overcome those challenges, and reach its goals in the medium-to-long term.

Among the major steps listed in the document is a strategy that has already gained widespread attention - the "dual circulation" model. In line with previous speeches from top officials, the communiqué called for forming a "powerful" domestic market and establishing a new growth model, where the internal circulation would play a main role in driving growth, though the external circulation would also be boosted. "Consumption would be boosted and room for investments would be expanded fully," the document said.

Though China is at a transitory period where both opportunities and challenges are abundant, "fully grasping the 'dual circulation' would turn this into a period of opportunities," Wang Huiyao, an adviser to China's State Council and president of the think tank Center for China and Globalization, told the Global Times on Thursday.

With China's exports, which have already been declining in recent years, facing a tough situation due to the raging pandemic and tensions, Chinese policymakers are counting on the massive domestic market to ensure economic growth and security. China, which already has a middle-income population of over 400 million, is set to overtake the US as the world's biggest consumer market in the coming years.

Aside from the "dual circulation" strategy, the communiqué also highlighted the country's focus on technological innovation to drive sustainable growth, calling it an "innovation-driven" development strategy, and aiming to become a global leader in innovation. The Chinese character for innovation appeared nearly 20 times in the document, and for technology, 13 times.

"One of the most important points in the communiqué is mentioning innovation as a core national strategy… Facing the complex global situation, China needs to improve these areas," Wang said.

However, as the communiqué has made clear, focusing on the internal circulation does not mean China will turn inward and stop its long-standing opening-up policies. China will firmly adhere to its opening-up paths, and will continuously expand opening-up at a higher level, the document said.

"When we talk about the 14th Five-Year Plan, we shouldn't stress its effect on domestic development. It also has a significant meaning globally. China's economy is the engine for the global economy. China achieving a strategic victory against the epidemic and sustained economic growth is also a dose of confidence for the world," Yang said.  

https://www.globaltimes.cn/content/1205131.shtml

Music Video - Boney M - Rasputin

Music Video - Billy Joel - We Didn't Start the Fire

Video Report - #Australia #CriminalResponsibility #RaiseTheAge Australia: Children as young as 10 are still being incarcerated

Video - France on two fronts: New wave of terror attacks ahead of return to lockdown

Video - Hear new audio from Kushner on Trump's Covid-19 response